WWE's Brie Bella recalls Paige's surprise return at WrestleMania 42: 'Magical moment'

The Bellas Turn the Tables on a WrestleMania Set‑up, Capturing the Women’s Tag Titles
In a surprise twist that had Las Vegas fans gasping, Paige’s unexpected return to the WWE ring at WrestleMania 42 allowed The Bellas—Nikki and Brie—to sidestep a potentially cancelled bout and claim the Women’s Tag Team Championship on the night of the show.
Nikki Bella had announced weeks earlier that she would be sidelined for WrestleMania with a fractured ankle. The announcement left her partner, Brie Bella, and the rest of the WWE roster scrambling to find a way to keep the two sisters in the ring. Brie was scheduled to team with her sister in a fatal four‑way match for the tag titles, but the ankle injury cast doubt on whether the pair could compete.
The plan fell apart the night before the event when Brie realized she could not safely step onto the stage. As she was about to leave, a familiar silhouette emerged from the crowd—a surprise appearance by Paige, the former WWE superstar who had been absent from television for months. Paige had been returning to the WWE after a long hiatus, and she announced her support for The Bellas right in front of the live audience and the television audience watching from home.
“Paige, we have so much history with, and she literally feels like a sister to me,” Brie told reporters in an interview with OutKick Dropkick after the match. “Going from such a down moment, finding out about Nikki’s broken ankle and then having Paige be able to step in, it just felt like a really magical moment and kind of like what pro wrestling is about.” She added, “Actually gives me goosebumps thinking about that moment because, honestly, I was like, OK, so we’re out of ‘Mania, and then I’ll wait ‘til Nikki gets better.”
Brie's words captured the emotional stakes of the night. Paige, who had been absent from WWE programming for almost a year, stepped in and joined The Bellas in a new, high‑profile partnership. Together, the trio entered the fatal four‑way tag match and outlasted three other teams to become the new Women’s Tag Team Champions. The teams defeated were Nia Jax and Lash Legend, Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss, and Bayley and Lyra Valkyria.
The victory was a turning point for both The Bellas and Paige. The match showcased the sisters’ chemistry, and Paige’s presence was widely praised by fans who felt that her return had added an extra layer of drama to the event. “I feel like we’re a great tag team together, and she agreed, and we have a lot of chemistry,” Brie said, recalling the camaraderie between the two women.
Later in the year, however, the newly formed duo began to unravel. In a title bout later in 2026, Fallon Henley and Lainey Reid captured the Women’s Tag Team Championship from Brie Bella and Paige. The loss was a blow to the partnership that had seemed to flourish at WrestleMania. A week later, at SummerSlam in Minneapolis, the storyline culminated with the two women going their separate ways. Paige and Nikki Bella had already been engaged in a brief feud earlier that year, adding additional layers of tension to the split.
In addition to the title loss, Brie Bella sustained a broken scapula at SummerSlam. She was forced to sit out several months of action while she recovered. The injury was discussed in a recent interview with OutKick Dropkick, in which she outlined her timeline for rehabilitation and when she might return to the ring.
The Bellas’ WrestleMania 42 run remains a memorable moment in WWE history. It demonstrated how a surprise return, combined with a clear narrative and real‑world injuries, can produce a compelling story that resonates with fans. While the partnership between Brie and Paige has since ended, the night’s triumph will linger in the memories of those who witnessed the unexpected teamwork that secured The Bellas a place in tag‑team lore.

