Mon, Nov 16WeatherBangor, ME
Maine Lottery
Latest draws loading
Maine News Now

Unannounced armed troops have no place in Portland | Opinion

Unannounced armed troops have no place in Portland | Opinion
100%

Portland, Maine – October 27, 2023
A retired librarian from Great Diamond Island reported seeing seven armed members of the Maine National Guard’s 11th Civil Support Team standing inside the Casco Bay Lines Ferry terminal on Monday morning. The personnel were dressed in black shirts, black bulletproof vests and khaki trousers, each wearing sidearms and vests that identified them as “Maine Civil Support.”

According to William Middleton, who observed the scene, the troops were not engaged in any interaction with ferry staff or passengers. “They were just standing there, as if their simple presence—armed and uniformed—was meant to provide safety,” Middleton said. “They weren’t exploring the terminal or talking to anyone; they were just there, visible and armed.”

The 11th Civil Support Team, based in Waterville, is a specialized unit of the Maine National Guard that assists local, state and federal first responders during natural and man‑made emergencies. The unit’s mission includes providing expertise in chemical, biological, radiological, nuclear and explosive (CBRNE) incidents, as well as supporting disaster response operations.

Middleton noted that the ferry terminal, a critical transportation hub for commuters traveling to and from Great Diamond Island, is often vulnerable to weather events and potential security concerns. While the presence of a civil support team is intended to enhance public safety, the observer said the sight of armed personnel in tactical gear made him feel less secure rather than more.

“It wasn’t the idea of protection that bothered me; it was how the display felt,” he explained. “Seeing people in full combat gear standing still without any clear reason reminded everyone in the building that the state has a monopoly on violence. That reminder isn’t comforting when you’re just trying to catch a ferry.”

Middleton added that he believed the troops did not need the equipment they were wearing for the purpose of their activity. “They could have performed the same function unarmed and in civilian clothes, and it wouldn’t have diminished the quality of their training,” he said. “If the goal is to reassure the public, having armed soldiers standing silently in a public space can have the opposite effect.”

The incident has sparked discussion among residents about the visibility of armed forces in everyday civilian settings. While Maine Civil Support teams are trained to respond to serious incidents, some community members are questioning the necessity and perception of such deployments in routine situations.

Middleton concluded, “I’m not against having a trained civil support team when there’s a real threat. What I’m against is normalizing armed soldiers in our town when they’re not needed, because that erodes the sense of safety we all want to feel.”

The ferry terminal has not released any official statement regarding the presence of the Guard personnel. Maine National Guard officials have not commented on the specific incident, but the 11th Civil Support Team remains on alert for potential emergencies across the state.

Author

Maine News Now

Maine News Now

Related Stories

Chiefs' Chris Jones explains why opinions 'are like buttholes' on national television
NATIONALopinion13 hours ago

Chiefs' Chris Jones explains why opinions 'are like buttholes' on national television

Maine’s workers found new voice in Troy Jackson | Opinion
opinion16 hours ago

Maine’s workers found new voice in Troy Jackson | Opinion

Hakeem Jeffries would be a first. That isn’t enough. | Opinion
opinion21 hours ago

Hakeem Jeffries would be a first. That isn’t enough. | Opinion