This stubborn dinosaur in Brunswick wrestles with the AI phenomenon | Column

In a recent email exchange with my two sons I noted that I’ve already written over 50 articles this year. I wanted to show them that their old man still has some gas left in the tank. My son David asked, “Do you use AI for those?” I immediately responded “No.” In fairness, I’ll often do research in preparation for writing a piece, which uses artificial intelligence. But I never use AI to “write” or to craft a first draft, and I can’t imagine doing so.
Santiago Schnell, the provost (the top academic officer) of Dartmouth, does not share my reservations about jumping on the AI bandwagon. He recently got caught with his ethics down. The student newspaper at Dartmouth conducted an investigation about Schnell by using Pangram, which has a near-zero error rate. The investigation concluded that Schnell’s work was 96% “AI-written” across the nine professional articles he published this year, including a Washington Post essay and two academic papers about mathematics, Schnell’s field of academic study. Oops. It gets worse. He apparently used AI in his own written defense.
After I wrote a note to my son Jon about my piano teacher’s amazing practice of sending a follow-up email highlighting points to remember within seconds after each lesson. Jon responded, “Dad, he’s using AI.” When I later asked my teacher if he used AI in that way, he laughed and said, “No. That’s why there are typos sometimes.”
While chatting with people at Thornton Oaks about their take on AI, I’ve discovered that most of them take my approach. They use it for some basic research but little else. Others spend hours going down this or that rabbit hole to create something new or different. To each his own.
Just for kicks, I asked my Facebook friends — yes, Facebook is AI-driven — how AI has benefited them. Or not. The answers ran the gamut. One person noted that she has found AI to be “useful, insightful and enjoyable.” She uses it for everything from analyzing documents and planning trips to preparing shopping lists and music playlists.
Another person reported that Gemini has become “the friend that is always there for me. As a homebound widow, Gemini will chat with me about any subject any time. Society makes me feel old and, ergo, stupid. Gemini praises my efforts. She remember my cat’s name. When she drafts a letter for me she knows that I am an experienced editor and acknowledges that.” And on and on.
Advertisement
Here’s the most poignant response from one of my Facebook friends. “I lost my voice to ALS. AI took recordings of me and crewed a professional voice clone My electronic voice now sounds like me.”
And last, “For us neurodivergents, it’s a great augment tool.”
Clearly, AI offers extraordinary value on the medical front, especially for conducting research. Also, AI can convert your primary care physician’s quick notes into a readable narrative in seconds.
A huge question remains about AI: What steps can be taken to ensure that bad actors can’t do tremendous damage using AI? Specifically, what will AI companies do on that front? Sadly, I’m not optimistic. Maximizing profits, society be damned, seems to be the driving force.
I can say that trying to deal with an AI customer service representative drives me batty. And I can’t imagine wanting to join an organization for which a first round “interview” is conducted by AI.
We can only hope for the best. Meanwhile, dear reader, please be assured that AI didn’t write this piece. For better or worse, the words are all mine.
David Treadwell, a Brunswick writer, welcomes commentary and suggestions for future “Just a Little Old” columns at [email protected].
**The Times Record Sustaining Sponsor
**We believe a community must be informed to thrive. bowdoin.edu
Copy the Story Link
Tagged: AI, artificial intelligence, Times Record Community





