Susan Collins could confront Trump | Letter

Maine senator urged to confront President Trump in letter to editor
Portland, Maine – A letter to the editor from Portland resident and academic Michael Hatem, Ph.D., has sparked discussion about how Maine’s U.S. senator might respond to former President Donald Trump’s presidency. Hatem, who posted the letter in the Portland Press Herald online, called on Senator Susan Collins to take a more direct stance against Trump’s actions, ranging from pardoning Jan. 6 participants to supporting policies he says have harmed the United States.
In the letter, Hatem listed a series of actions he says Trump has taken that he believes “degraded the presidency and the United States.” Those included:
- pardoning individuals involved in the Jan. 6 insurrection;
- backing the cryptocurrency DOGE;
- allegedly covering up details in the Jeffrey Epstein files;
- launching a war against Iran;
- expanding U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) presence on U.S. soil;
- pursuing personal vendettas through lawsuits;
- imposing rounds of tariffs;
- “bombing fishermen” and other military actions; and
- supporting the governments of Vladimir Putin and Benjamin Netanyahu.
He accused Trump of “degrading the presidency and the United States” and urged Collins to confront him personally, describing such a confrontation as “an on‑the‑ground, human thing” that would involve speaking directly with colleagues and persuading them to act.
Collins, who represents Maine in the U.S. Senate, responded to the letter with a formal reply. In it, she explained that procedural constraints limit her ability to act on the matters he raised. She noted that impeachment is a process that begins in the House of Representatives, moves through the Senate, and ultimately requires a Senate vote. “If representatives initiate the process, and representatives and then senators moved it along, up to a Senate vote — then, following deliberation, she would be counted, Nay or Yea,” she wrote, paraphrasing the constitutional procedure for impeachment.
Hatem, in his reply, offered his support, saying he would be willing to accompany Collins and speak alongside her. “I have suggested that I accompany Susan, even do the speaking,” he wrote. He also pointed out that Collins has “agency enough to confront Donald Trump,” suggesting that more could be done than the procedural explanation he received.
The letter and Collins’s response drew attention to the broader debate over the role of individual senators in holding the president accountable. While Collins has been known for her independent stances on various issues—often voting against the party line—she has not yet taken a public position calling for direct action against Trump’s policies.
The letter was posted on the Press Herald’s online platform under the tag “letter to the editor.” It has prompted several readers to comment on the limits of congressional power and the ways senators can influence the course of U.S. politics when the executive branch is at odds with the legislature.
For now, Hatem’s call remains a plea for more decisive action from Maine’s senator, while Collins’s explanation underscores the procedural nature of congressional authority. Whether either party will move forward with a public confrontation remains to be seen.


