Mon, Nov 16WeatherBangor, ME
Maine Lottery
Latest draws loading
Maine News Now

STU BURGUIERE: Put your money where your mouth is: Prediction markets won the midterms

STU BURGUIERE: Put your money where your mouth is: Prediction markets won the midterms
100%

Millions of dollars poured into mid‑term ads; prediction markets rise as new gauge of accuracy

In the 2026 U.S. mid‑term elections, political campaigns spent a record‑breaking $12.8 billion on advertising, the largest sum ever devoted to a congressional campaign cycle. Texas, a state with a highly contested Senate race, saw nearly $573 million earmarked for political ads, putting its race among the most expensive in non‑presidential history.

Campaigns, pundits, super PACs and the mainstream media all made a single, confident statement: “We will win.” Analysts predicted their numbers would hold true, and advertisers touted their candidates’ “best policies and character.” The result was a flood of television and online ads that pitted candidates against each other in high‑stakes accusations.

While campaign spending exploded, a parallel industry grew behind the scenes. Over the last few years, more than $1.3 billion has been staked in prediction markets that allow anyone to bet on the outcome of elections. Traders buy and sell contracts that pay out when a candidate wins, when a party takes control of Congress, or when a particular policy measure passes. The idea is simple: those who believe a race will swing a certain way must put money at risk.

In 2026, the most active market on the platform Kalshi recorded 2.24 million resolved trades from its 2021 launch to the present. Across those markets, prices were tightly calibrated to reality. When a contract was trading at 30 cents, the outcome occurred about 30 percent of the time; at 90 cents, it happened roughly 90 percent of the time. Independent researchers at Brier.fyi, who track more than 74 k Kalshi markets, confirmed similar accuracy rates. A recent study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences examined over one million resolved predictions across four platforms and found that the probability implied by a market price matched the real‑world frequency of the event.

On Election Day itself, Kalshi’s markets correctly identified the winner in 98 percent of the tracked federal contests, including non‑competitive incumbents and tightly contested battlegrounds. Even when a race produced a surprise outcome—such as Democrat Annie Andrews defeating Republican Senator Darline Graham in South Carolina—her contract had traded at about a 1‑in‑3 probability. As one market participant put it, “If underdogs never won, the markets wouldn’t be working. Upsets like hers are exactly what a 1‑in‑3 price promises.”

Critics argue that prediction markets are still too new to be reliable, and that a handful of upsets could undermine confidence. Senators have issued letters cautioning against “election contracts,” and some states have pursued lawsuits or outright bans. Yet the data suggests that markets are a useful complement to traditional polling. “They don’t have to be perfect to be useful,” one commentator said. “They’re an incredible addition to the polling, forecasting, and reporting we already have, and they make all of it better.”

The rise of prediction markets also carries implications for journalism. As newsrooms trim staff and data desks are among the first to face cuts, the ability to price in the likelihood of an outcome provides a new source of reliable, real‑time information. “When information is worth money, someone will pay for it,” a market participant said. “That means more research, more deep‑dive reporting and more jobs for data nerds. That’s a win for all of us.”

Beyond the economic angle, the markets act as a public check on spin. Politicians and campaign teams can no longer claim a race is “in the bag” without facing a financial penalty if they are wrong. The price of a contract reflects the aggregate judgment of a diverse group of people, making it a hard‑to‑manipulate barometer of public sentiment.

In short, the 2026 mid‑terms showcased a dual trend: unprecedented spending on political advertising and the emergence of prediction markets as a statistically robust indicator of electoral outcomes. While the markets are not infallible, their track record—both in the week before Election Day and in the months after—suggests they can provide voters, journalists, and policymakers with a clearer, data‑driven view of the political landscape.

Author

Maine News Now

Maine News Now

Related Stories

On the market: Dining rooms fit for holiday feasting
business2 days ago

On the market: Dining rooms fit for holiday feasting

High mortgage rates put a damper on Maine’s housing market
business3 days ago

High mortgage rates put a damper on Maine’s housing market

UN renews Iran's committee seat amid war with US, sparking backlash: 'Morally bankrupt'
NATIONALbusiness3 days ago

UN renews Iran's committee seat amid war with US, sparking backlash: 'Morally bankrupt'