South Portland tank farms require strongest possible action | Opinion

South Portland residents are calling for tighter controls on the city’s massive oil storage facilities after a new study confirmed that benzene levels around several of the tanks exceed state standards. The call for action came at a city council meeting on Tuesday, when the mayor urged officials to adopt stronger measures to protect air quality in the Pleasantdale neighborhood.
Citgo, a subsidiary of Irving Oil, operates 120 above‑ground petroleum storage tanks along South Portland’s waterfront, most of them clustered in the Pleasantdale district. A recent monitoring campaign by the Maine Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) found that the air around at least five of Citgo’s facilities, including the 18‑tank plant on Mechanic Street, consistently recorded benzene concentrations above the long‑term health‑based standard set by the state. Benzene is a known carcinogen and has been linked to a range of respiratory and cardiovascular problems.
The data were collected by a network of 18 air quality monitors placed around the tanks’ fencelines, a project that was the result of years of pressure from local community groups such as Protect South Portland. “People have lived with these tank farms next to them for generations, yet their concerns about choking fumes, headaches and long‑term health risks have been dismissed by oil companies and regulators alike,” said Chelsea Byun, a resident and volunteer with Protect South Portland. Byun added that the new findings confirm what residents had suspected for decades.
Citgo’s reaction came only a day after the council hearing. Vice President of Marketing Karl Schmidt issued a press release to the Press Herald and local officials pledging “quick action to reduce emissions and monitor the facility’s effects on the neighborhood.” In the release, the company highlighted its economic benefits to the city with a bold claim, “At Citgo, people come first.” However, the statement offered no concrete plan for emission reductions, nor did any company representative speak publicly during the council meeting about how the issue would be addressed.
Mayor Elyse Tipton was quick to call the lack of substantive action “unacceptable.” “Testing in the absence of further action is not acceptable for our community,” she said, urging the council to move beyond data collection and toward enforcement. The mayor’s remarks come after a history of regulatory inaction. In 2019, the DEP acknowledged that two South Portland tank farms had violated the Clean Air Act but chose not to pursue enforcement, a decision the agency later admitted was wrong when it faced a federal crackdown on oil‑tank pollution. Since then, city officials and residents have repeatedly requested more comprehensive testing and regulatory oversight.
The city council announced that it will hold a public workshop on December 1 to explore options for reducing emissions. Potential strategies include a local ordinance mandating emissions controls, a revised licensing scheme for tank farms, or seeking state‑level legislation to impose stricter limits on the industry. Residents and community organizers, including Lucy Perkins, a representative‑elect for House District 121, are pressing for immediate action.
The Mechanic Street tank farm is not only an industrial site; it borders residential homes, a popular walking and biking path, and a new city playground that draws children and families every weekend. The facility is a major employer, with nine workers on site and hundreds of visitors arriving daily to off‑load fuel or transport it to other parts of the state.
Citgo’s acknowledgement of its impact is a first in the city’s long history of environmental oversight. Still, many residents argue that a single statement does not address the underlying health risks. “We want to know how long the company intends to keep its emissions at current levels,” said Byun. “We also want to see measurable reductions and a plan that holds the company accountable.”
The city council’s upcoming workshop is seen as a crucial step toward ensuring that South Portland’s residents can enjoy clean air in their neighborhoods. As the council deliberates, community leaders are hopeful that a combination of local action and state cooperation will finally bring the much‑needed emissions controls to the area’s tank farms.




