South Portland schools vote down AI moratorium

The South Portland School Board voted down a temporary moratorium of generative AI use for kindergarten through eighth grade students on Monday.
Many school board members said that artificial intelligence is a pressing matter for educators and policy makers to reckon with, but they said they trust the administration’s plan to develop sensible policy recommendations.
The AI steering committee will present its findings to the board in January, including guidelines, ethics language, examples of expected and prohibited use, and charts delineating different options for different age groups, according to Andy Wallace, the technology director.
“Things have to change,” Wallace said. “This is a huge moment in education.”
Claire Holman, who brought forth the motion, was the only board member who voted in support of a moratorium, calling the issue “an emergency.” Member Daniel Feller was absent.
Related
South Portland schools may temporarily ban AI
Superintendent Angela Atkinson Duina said she feels confident in educators’ judgment and has faith in the steering committee’s work. She said board members should feel empowered to provide guidance to the committee.
Advertisement
School Board Member Tyler Smith said it would be an overstep for the board to disregard the advice it’s hearing from specialists like Wallace and educators who are working with the technology on a daily basis.
“We don’t know enough about what’s going on in these classrooms to make a decision,” he said.
A few teachers and school librarians shared how the temporary moratorium would have directly interfered with their planned curriculum.
Cidney Mayes, a librarian at the middle school, said that the last four weeks of her course is dedicated to AI. She walks students through how it works, the pros and cons and the environmental impacts.
“My job is not to tell kids what to think about it,” she said. “My job is to give them the critical thinking skills to make the decisions for themselves about what they think about AI.”
By requiring administrative approval for each use, the moratorium would have directly impacted her curriculum, she said.
Advertisement
Sarah Gay, the president of the teacher’s union, said that her bargaining unit did not have enough information or time to prepare a unified statement.
Under the proposed moratorium, all staff members would be required to receive two hours of AI awareness training and three hours of AI literacy training by the end of the school year. Afterward, teachers would only be able to use tools sanctioned by the school district on school-issued devices. No teacher would be required to use student-facing AI.
Some educators who spoke at the board meething said that the district should bring back the technology integration specialist, a position that was cut in the budget a couple of years ago.
Mike McCann, who used to hold that position, said that hands-on support can help teachers decide what appropriate use looks like.
Copy the Story Link
Tagged: artificial intelligence, education, south portland school board
Dana Richie is a community reporter covering South Portland and Cape Elizabeth. Originally from Atlanta, she fell in love with the landscape and quirks of coastal New England while completing her undergraduate. More by Dana Richie



