South Portland schools may temporarily ban AI

South Portland School Board to Vote on AI Moratorium for Pre‑K‑8 Students
South Portland, Maine – The South Portland School Board will decide this Monday whether to suspend the use of generative artificial intelligence tools, including ChatGPT‑style chatbots, for students in pre‑kindergarten through eighth grade for the remainder of the 2025‑26 school year and through the 2026‑27 school year. The proposed moratorium would also restrict teachers to only those AI programs that the district explicitly approves and would require staff to complete training before any AI could be used in classrooms.
The move follows a growing national debate over the role of AI in education, with cities such as New York and Los Angeles recently banning student access to these tools in elementary and middle schools. In Maine, there is no statewide policy, but the Department of Education encourages districts to develop “thoughtful, ethical integration” of AI and has released a toolkit to assist schools in crafting their own guidelines. The governor’s office also formed a 21‑member task force on AI that released a report last fall outlining recommendations for the state.
The Proposal
Under the resolution, every South Portland teacher would have to complete two hours of AI awareness training and three hours of AI literacy training by the end of the school year. After that, teachers would only be allowed to use AI tools that the district sanctions, and only on school‑issued devices. No teacher would be required to use student‑facing AI, though the ban would not extend to technology specifically designed for students with disabilities or English‑language learners. The board has also indicated that certain approved instruction—such as coding or simulation‑based learning—could be exempt from the moratorium.
“We need to start somewhere,” said Claire Holman, the board member who introduced the resolution. “ChatGPT is only a couple of years old, and people are trying to figure out what we should do now.” Holman also cited concerns that AI use could hinder the development of critical thinking skills. “They don’t learn to struggle and push through when something gets difficult,” she said. “If we rely too heavily on instant answers, we might lose that foundational learning process.”
The proposal has no explicit enforcement plan, raising worries that students may find ways to circumvent the ban. Holman acknowledged that “there is some concern that students could find ways to work around it,” but insisted that the district needs a starting point as it develops a more comprehensive policy.
Voices from the Classroom
School Board member Daniel Feller, a “power user” of AI who has worked in biomedical informatics for a decade, has been asking questions about how best to approach AI in schools. “I think community members, teachers, and administrators need to consider these issues as well,” Feller said. “We don’t want to have a wait‑and‑see approach of seeing what the impact on our kids will be. We really want to be confident that we’re doing it in an intentional way with something as powerful as AI.”
Feller’s stance reflects a broader conversation among educators in the district. Sarah Gay, an English teacher and president of the teachers’ union, has integrated AI into her lessons to simplify texts to students’ reading levels and to translate materials for families of multilingual learners. “I do think that there are cases to be made for some of the tools,” she said. “And I think the most commonly used are probably also the most benign, I hope.” Gay also noted that teachers “need more training about the tools and how to teach students with access to the technology.” She added that the collective knowledge about AI’s role in education is “virtually non‑existent.”
South Portland has already experimented with AI in the classroom. Under the guidance of Technology Director Andy Wallace, the district has implemented a closed‑source program called MagicSchool, which does not train itself on user data. The platform allows teachers to control what students see and to use AI for math problem‑solving, essay proofreading, and general question‑answering. The program is designed to keep AI’s use focused and teacher‑directed, a feature that some board members see as a model for a broader policy.
A National Context
The moratorium proposal mirrors actions taken in other parts of the country. New York’s school districts have imposed temporary bans on AI tools for elementary and middle school students, while Los Angeles Unified School District has restricted all students from using AI tools. Across the country, many districts are drafting policies that balance the potential benefits of AI—such as personalized learning and skill development for a tech‑driven economy—with concerns about academic integrity, critical thinking, and equity.
In Maine, the Department of Education has emphasized “thoughtful, ethical integration of AI in education,” and the governor’s AI task force recommends that elementary students not use chatbots, citing research that shows students who rely on AI for rapid answers may experience a drop in performance when the technology is removed. The American Federation of Teachers echoes that sentiment, advocating for hands‑on learning over chatbot reliance for younger students.
Next Steps
If the board votes in favor of the moratorium, the district will move forward with the outlined training and policy development. The resolution also leaves




