Scarborough changes tree clearing rules after cutting controversies


An eastern bluebird perches on a branch of a dead tree in Scarborough Marsh in 2023. (Gregory Rec/Staff Photographer)
The Scarborough Town Council passed amendments to the town’s ordinances last week to address concerns and complaints about tree clearing.
Councilor Karin Schupe said the council has consistently received complaints about tree cutting, and the orders it passed to address them have been years in the making.
The first order changes the zoning to include a requirement for a 20-foot streetscape buffer for most streets. Many of the primary roadways already had a 25- to 35-foot streetscape buffer, but other streets didn’t have any requirements.
The second order changes the process for code enforcement cases and site plan reviews.
It also establishes protections for certain types of trees, including “significant” and “heritage” trees. Significant trees are non-invasive trees with a minimum diameter at breast height of 24 inches, and they must be preserved or, if removed, replaced at a ratio of two and a half trees to one. Heritage trees have a minimum diameter of 60 inches or meet other criteria, and they must be preserved or replaced at a ratio of five trees to one.
The orders will only apply to commercial properties, not residential properties.
Advertisement
During the council meeting, residents and councilors made multiple references to the trees cut at Eight Corners to build the Nonesuch River Apartments a few years ago.
“I have yet to speak to someone who wasn’t shocked and horrified by how it looks,” resident Averyl Hill said at the council meeting before the vote. “Yet that massive clear-cutting without any tree buffer was and is permitted under our current ordinance.”
Related
Business owner clear-cut land in Scarborough without approval
The environment and sustainability are high priorities for many Scarborough residents, who are proud of the town’s marsh, beaches and other natural landmarks.
“That’s what makes Scarborough special,” Schupe said.
Besides addressing conservation concerns, Schupe said, the tree amendments could act as a mechanism to ensure growth and development in Scarborough is done thoughtfully and in an environmentally friendly manner.
One of the Town Council’s goals in 2026 was to limit tree cutting for new commercial developments.
Advertisement
Outgoing councilor Lawrence Cain proposed a few amendments at the order’s second reading, which were all approved.
One of the amendments changed the size of a significant tree from 20 to 24 inches in diameter, reducing the number of trees that can be considered significant trees. Another amendment increased the spacing allowed between trees from 15 to 20 feet on buffer strips, increasing a property’s visibility. Cain also proposed an amendment allowing the planning board to decrease the required buffer by up to 10 feet for some new developments.
The goal, Cain said, was to give property owners more leeway and limit how much the town is restricting how they can use their property. Too many tree-based restrictions could devalue properties, he said.
Schupe and some residents raised concerns during the second reading about making significant changes to the orders, especially after they had already been through the conservation commission, the ordinance committee, the planning board and the Town Council multiple times.
Correction: An earlier version of this story misspelled Averyl Hill’s first name.
Copy the Story Link
Tagged: business, environment, scarborough town council, trees
Salomé Cloteaux is a community reporter covering Scarborough and Westbrook. She was born in France but lived in Indiana for most of her life before moving to Portland in November 2025. Salomé has a degree. More by Salomé Cloteaux





