Mon, Nov 16WeatherBangor, ME
Maine Lottery
Latest draws loading
Maine News Now

Portland officials remain at odds with rail authority about plan to move Downeaster train station

Portland officials remain at odds with rail authority about plan to move Downeaster train station
100%

The Downeaster backtracks near St. John Street in Portland last month. The train's operator and city of Portland staff still disagree on where a new train station should be located. (Daryn Slover/Staff Photographer)

Portland city officials are still not convinced the proposal to relocate the Downeaster train station to outer St. John Street is the right path forward.

The Portland City Council members heard from stakeholders and weighed in with their opinions at a workshop on Monday, where they decided they will vote on one of three recommendations at a council meeting in December.

In August, the Northern New England Passenger Rail Authority, which operates the Downeaster, received $48 million in federal funding to relocate the train service’s Portland station to the authority’s preferred spot.

Related

Downeaster gets millions to relocate Portland train station

However, city staff and elected officials were caught off guard by that announcement because of a lack of local and regional support for the authority’s preferred location, as well as their own preference for using Union Station Plaza, farther down St. John Street.

Advertisement

Rail authority officials have argued that the move from the Portland Transportation Center to a swath of land between St. John Street and Northern Light Mercy Hospital would reduce travel time by roughly 15 minutes and expand rail service, and that its application for the funding was for that specific location.

The project is estimated to cost roughly $60 million, with a proposed $12 million match in state funding.

The three options the council will consider are to recommend the train station be left where it is; that the city’s preferred site be further explored; or that the rail authority’s preferred site move forward, with stipulations around other enhancements in the area.

Representatives from the rail authority, Greater Portland Council of Governments, and city staff outlined their arguments at — and ahead of — the workshop on Monday.

In a memo issued before the workshop, city staff recommended against proceeding with the train station relocation and suggested that the state prioritize transportation funding for more urgent needs. Staff say the rail authority’s preferred site goes against nearly every zoning and long-term planning document in place, and that its chosen location is heavily weighted toward rail operations.

An analysis from city staff said Union Station Plaza would provide better bicycle and pedestrian access and better public transit connections, noting that it’s closer to Congress Street workplaces, businesses, residential neighborhoods and recreational sites like Hadlock Field.

Advertisement

The rail authority has argued that its chosen site would strengthen pedestrian mobility between two areas of the city — the Fore River Parkway/Libbytown neighborhood and the West End/Western Promenade — that are currently split by the railroad.

At Monday’s workshop, it also cited barriers to the city’s preferred site, including a lack of needed buy-in from the county and MaineHealth to make it work.

A GPCOG memo, written by Executive Director Kristina Egan, argues that moving the station from its current location would weaken the transportation hub at Thompson’s Point by splitting rail from buses.

“Should we spend $60 million in public dollars to move the station away from the
connections we’ve already built?” she said.

According to a memo, the city and GPCOG staff previously outlined concerns with the rail authority’s process and suggested that the advantages of Union Station warranted a more in-depth analysis that compared both St. John Street options to the existing Thompson’s Point location. However, that analysis was never completed, and staff said a subsequent effort to engage a mediator reached “an early impasse.”

City staff and GPCOG also argue that the proposed $12 million in state funds has not yet been committed to the new station, and that if the funding did become available, it should be spent on higher priorities in the region.

Advertisement

Those include a new Metro facility and buses, and needed pedestrian infrastructure along corridors like Forest Avenue, as well as elsewhere in southern Maine, the GPCOG memo states.

“This is a discretionary project, and Portland and the region face substantial state funding limitations related to higher-priority needs … that would benefit more people,” Kevin Kraft, the city’s planning director, said before the meeting.

GPCOG also said using the state funding on the station instead of on Metro infrastructure “widens the equity gap.” The presentation says 86% of bus riders have household incomes of under $50,000 compared to just 5% of train riders.

This rendering shows a planned new Amtrak Downeaster train station off St. John Street in Portland. The operators of the Downeaster received $48 million in federal funding to relocate the station, but Portland officials continue to oppose the chosen site. (Image courtesy of Northern New England Passenger Rail Authority)

An estimated $4 million of the $60 million budget would go toward the costs of property acquisition, which the city says would displace several businesses. The staff memo said the location at Union Station, which is owned by MaineHealth, could move forward without displacement.

Mayor Mark Dion has previously said that MaineHealth has not been interested in selling, which complicates the city’s position.

Councilors Wes Pelletier and Regina Phillips were ardent in their opposition to the rail authority’s preferred site and the process to date.

Advertisement

“For us to get strong-armed like this, we are not a partner,” Pelletier said.

Councilor Sarah Michniewicz said she was not certain the 15-minute gain for rail passengers outweighs the drawbacks of the authority’s preferred site.

“I’m not sure that the motivation to relocate the entire station makes sense,” she said.

Councilor Kate Sykes expressed openness to making the authority’s preferred site work, noting that $48 million is a lot of money not to use.

Dion also expressed the need to be open, noting the city doesn’t have “a veto,” and rather can only make a recommendation and hope the rail authority and state comply.

“Unless somebody can tell me that we have the ability to veto … then we should devote our energies to provide what we can do to make (the rail authority’s preferred site) the best possible site,” he said.

Copy the Story Link

Tagged: amtrak downeaster, Portland City Council

Andrew RiceStaff Writer

Andrew Rice is a staff writer at the Press Herald covering the city of Portland. He's been working in journalism since 2012, joining the Sun Journal in 2017, then the Press Herald in 2026. He lives in. More by Andrew Rice

Drew JohnsonStaff Writer

Drew is the night reporter for the Portland Press Herald. He previously covered South Portland, Scarborough and Cape Elizabeth for the Sentry, Leader and Southern Forecaster. Though he is from Massachusetts,. More by Drew Johnson

Author

Maine News Now

Maine News Now

Related Stories

Westbrook residents work to 'Stuff-A-Bus' with cash and food for families in need
local3 hours ago

Westbrook residents work to 'Stuff-A-Bus' with cash and food for families in need

The Old Town Grinch hands out candy canes and collects food for neighbors in need
local8 hours ago

The Old Town Grinch hands out candy canes and collects food for neighbors in need

17-year-old boy missing in Caribou
local14 hours ago

17-year-old boy missing in Caribou