Paul Skenes and Livvy Dunne's Halloween costume will enrage anyone tired of rushing through holidays

Pirates’ Paul Skenes and Girlfriend Livvy Dunne Post Christmas‑Themed Halloween Costumes

Pittsburgh – Pittsburgh Pirates starting pitcher Paul Skenes and his girlfriend Livvy Dunne surprised fans with a pair of holiday‑themed Halloween costumes posted on social media on October 31, 2023.

Skenes and Dunne shared photos and video of the pair in costume during the day, a move that caught the attention of both sports and pop‑culture communities. Skenes, who has been a mainstay on the Pirates’ rotation since the 2023 season, posed in a Buddy the Elf costume from the 2003 film Elf, while Dunne walked in a bottle‑shaped costume that mimicked Mrs. Butterworth’s syrup, the sugary sweetener featured in the movie. The duo’s outfits combined the campy humor of the film with a playful nod to Christmas.

The couple’s social media post, which appeared on their personal Instagram and TikTok accounts, showcased a quick montage of them laughing while posing in the costumes, as well as a short clip of Skenes attempting to mimic the character’s signature “I’m elf” laugh. In the accompanying caption, Dunne wrote, “Just two of us getting in the spirit of the holiday!” The post has since accumulated thousands of likes and comments from fans, many of whom praised the creative and tongue‑in‑cheek approach.

Skenes, who has previously spoken about his love for the holiday season, said in a brief statement that he wanted to “bring a little extra holiday cheer to Halloween.” He added that the costumes were chosen because they “made sense to them both and were a lot of fun.”

The couple’s choice of a Christmas‑themed costume on Halloween drew mixed reactions. Some fans appreciated the creative mash‑up and the nostalgia for the 2003 film, while others joked that the couple was “getting ahead of their Christmas planning.” The playful spirit of the costumes was noted by several sports writers who highlighted how athletes often use social media to share their personal lives and interests.

The post is part of a broader trend of athletes and celebrities using Halloween as a platform to share light‑hearted and often quirky content with fans. While some costumes this year have leaned toward classic spooky themes, others—including the Skenes/Dunne pairing—have chosen unexpected and humorous concepts, reflecting the wide range of creative expressions embraced by fans.

As the holiday season approaches, the pair’s costumes serve as a reminder that Halloween can be a space for playful experimentation. Whether fans agree or disagree with the Christmas‑themed approach, the post underscores the growing role of social media as a venue for personal expression among athletes and their loved ones.