Mon, Nov 16WeatherBangor, ME
Maine Lottery
Latest draws loading
Maine News Now

Newsom’s death-row commutations spark DA revolt as prosecutors warn of legal fight

Newsom’s death-row commutations spark DA revolt as prosecutors warn of legal fight
100%

California Governor’s Death‑Row Commutation Sparks Widespread Legal Pushback

In a move that has drawn sharp criticism from across the state’s prosecutorial ranks, California Governor Gavin Newsom announced Thursday a plan to commute every one of the 548 death sentences in the state to life in prison without parole. The proposal, which Newsom says aligns the state’s punishment system with “California’s values,” would effectively eliminate the death penalty as it exists today, although it does not repeal the statute.

The announcement triggered an outpouring of statements from at least a dozen county district attorneys, all of whom argued that the blanket order undermines the jury system, disregards the wishes of victims’ families, and bypasses the will of voters who have repeatedly expressed support for capital punishment in the ballot box.

How the Plan Works

Under the governor’s proposal, all death sentences would be converted to life‑without‑parole (LWOP) sentences. However, the California Supreme Court has stipulated that 382 of those cases still require approval from at least four justices before a commutation can take effect. The Associated Press reported that the state’s Board of Parole Hearings has, as of Oct. 1, adopted regulations that allow thousands of inmates serving LWOP to become eligible for parole. Newsom’s office, however, maintains that those inmates will remain in prison and are not eligible for release under the new commutation.

“We are not changing the law that makes the death penalty possible; we are merely commuting existing sentences,” the governor’s office said. The clemency announcement was made public on Thursday, the same day the proposal was unveiled to the press.

District Attorneys’ Response

Thien Ho, Sacramento County
“Justice requires case‑by‑case consideration, not one‑size‑fits‑all decisions,” said Ho in a statement. He warned that a mass commutation would override the individualized determinations made by juries and appellate courts over many years.

Todd Spitzer, Orange County
Spitzer dismissed the governor’s action as “mercy for the wolves” and added that it would “inflict the ultimate act of cruelty on the sheep.” He cited the Board of Parole Hearings regulations, arguing that Newsom’s commutations could move some inmates “one step closer” to release. The Orange County office added that the governor’s office has assured inmates that they will not be released.

Jason Anderson, San Bernardino County
Anderson called the move a political power grab. “The Governor is attempting to appear courageous with this decision. He is not courageous. His commutations are solely based upon power and political aspirations,” Anderson said. He pointed to the case of Kevin Cooper, a death‑row inmate convicted of a triple homicide, noting that Newsom has never contacted the families of the victims or even reached out to the mother of one of the victims, Mary Ann Hughes. Anderson said the governor’s actions violate Marsy’s Law, the state’s victim‑rights statute, and that no victims’ families have been notified of the commutations.

Dan Dow, San Luis Obispo County
Dow warned that a single order “would set aside hundreds of individualized judgments without examining the facts of even one.” He added that the decision “invalidates the exhausting, emotionally wrenching work of our citizens who sat on juries, weighed horrific evidence, and delivered lawful verdicts.”

Ron Freitas, San Joaquin County
Freitas said the governor’s action “tears wounds wide open all over again.” He criticized the blanket commutation as a “mass erasure of justice” that ignores the repeated ballot‑box approvals of Proposition 66 in 2016, which streamlined death‑sentence appeals, and the voter rejection of repeal initiatives in 2012 and 2016.

Summer Stephan, San Diego County
Stephan announced that her office is “researching any lawful remedies” that might allow victims’ voices to be heard and considered. The statement was issued shortly after the announcement, hinting at possible legal challenges.

Cynthia Zimmer, Kern County
Zimmer was more direct in her response, stating that the “assault on justice will be challenged.” Her office has not yet issued a formal legal brief, but the statement suggests forthcoming action.

Nathan Hochman, Los Angeles County
Hochman acknowledged that the governor has constitutional authority to commute sentences but clarified that his power does not extend to eliminating the death penalty altogether. “Only the Legislature or the voters can do that,” Hochman said.

Legal Context

The California Supreme Court’s requirement for approval in 382 cases introduces a check on the governor’s commutation power. The court’s four‑justice majority decision is still pending, and the outcomes could determine whether a subset of the death sentences remain subject to the governor’s discretion. The court’s involvement also highlights the tension between executive clemency and judicial review.

California voters have, over the past decade, expressed a consistent preference for retaining the death penalty. In 2012, 54% of voters rejected a repeal initiative. In 2016, voters again turned down a repeal and instead approved Proposition 66, which amended the death‑penalty procedure to expedite appeals. Critics argue that Newsom’s sweeping commutation negates the results of those voter decisions without legislative or electoral input.

Broader Implications

The commutation proposal is the latest in a long line of debates over capital punishment in the state. The governor’s statement that the move is “incompatible with California’s values” frames it as a moral stance, yet it also raises questions about the role of the executive in criminal justice policy. District attorneys argue that the decision bypasses the jury system, which they say is the cornerstone of California’s criminal process.

Some prosecutors, such as Anderson, have highlighted the potential impact on victims’ families. Anderson’s reference to the Kevin Cooper case underscores the personal dimensions of the debate. He noted that the governor’s office has not contacted the families of Cooper’s victims, a move he deems inconsistent with the state’s victim‑rights law.

The Board of Parole Hearings’ recent regulation change adds another layer of complexity. The new rules would allow thousands of LWOP inmates to be considered for parole. While the governor’s office insists that commuted death‑row inmates will remain incarcerated, the possibility of parole for LWOP prisoners has prompted concerns that the commutation could indirectly facilitate releases.

Next Steps

A number of county district attorneys have signaled that they will explore legal avenues to challenge the commutation order. “We are researching any lawful remedies,” said Stephan. “We are also preparing to challenge the governor’s actions where we see fit.” No specific legal filings have been announced yet, but the statements suggest that a court battle may be imminent.

The governor’s office has yet to respond to Fox News Digital’s request for comment, and it remains unclear how the executive branch will defend the broad nature of the commutation in the face of widespread prosecutorial opposition.

As the debate unfolds, the fate of the 548 death sentences—and the broader question of how California should address capital punishment—will remain a central issue for voters, lawmakers, and the state’s justice community.

Author

Maine News Now

Maine News Now

Related Stories

49ers offense puts up over 580 yards against a bad Cowboys defense behind a Christian McCaffrey masterclass
NATIONALnational5 hours ago

49ers offense puts up over 580 yards against a bad Cowboys defense behind a Christian McCaffrey masterclass

Pete Buttigieg breaks with Democrats on student loan handouts, admits party ‘overtorqued’ on issue
NATIONALnational5 hours ago

Pete Buttigieg breaks with Democrats on student loan handouts, admits party ‘overtorqued’ on issue

Lane Kiffin blames LSU's $40+ million roster after loss to Texas: 'we'll have better rosters’
NATIONALnational6 hours ago

Lane Kiffin blames LSU's $40+ million roster after loss to Texas: 'we'll have better rosters’