Mon, Nov 16WeatherBangor, ME
Maine Lottery
Latest draws loading
Maine News Now

Matt Dunlap conceded to Paul LePage, but they’re headed to a ranked-choice runoff anyway

Matt Dunlap conceded to Paul LePage, but they’re headed to a ranked-choice runoff anyway
100%

LePage Holds 5,400-Vote Lead as Dunlap Concedes; Ranked-Choice Runoff Still Set for Monday

AUGUSTA — Democratic State Auditor Matt Dunlap conceded Maine’s 2nd Congressional District race Thursday, but Republican Paul LePage’s path to Congress still runs through a ranked-choice runoff scheduled to begin Monday in the state capital.

LePage, the former governor, leads Dunlap by 5,400 votes with results reported from every municipality in the district. Yet neither candidate has cleared the 50 percent threshold required to win outright under Maine law, because more than 6,000 voters left the congressional portion of their ballots blank. LePage is just 316 votes short of that mark.

In a written statement, Dunlap congratulated LePage and wished him well, while acknowledging his own disappointment. “This isn’t the result we were hoping for, and I’m disappointed that we came short,” Dunlap said. “Congratulations to Paul LePage, I wish him the best.”

Despite the concession, Secretary of State Shenna Bellows confirmed that the ranked-choice process will go forward as planned. Maine law requires a runoff whenever no candidate receives first-choice rankings on more than half of all ballots cast for an office, and the state counts blank ballots toward that total.

Beginning Monday in Augusta, tabulators will first verify the accuracy of the vote count—a process Bellows likened to a full recount. They will then set aside ballots with no selections whatsoever, count ballots that skipped the first choice but marked a second, and tabulate second-choice votes from ballots where voters wrote in another name. That group includes 123 votes for declared write-in candidate Gregory A. Ward, along with an undetermined number of other write-in votes.

It remains unknown how many blank ballots fall into each category, or how many write-in voters ranked LePage or Dunlap as their second choice.

The concession does not alter the legal count. Bellows pointed to a 2018 precedent, when a Republican gubernatorial primary advanced to a ranked-choice runoff even after losing candidates conceded and their party argued the process was unnecessary.

The Associated Press has not called the race for LePage. The news organization said it only declares a winner when it is unquestionably impossible for the trailing candidate to catch up. Because the ranked-choice review could theoretically change the outcome, and because the contents of the blank ballots are still unknown, AP said it must wait.

LePage’s campaign declared victory Wednesday, arguing the result is effectively settled. Senior adviser Brent Littlefield said it is “very clear” that LePage is the congressman-elect.

If the arithmetic holds as expected, LePage would become the only Republican in this cycle’s Democratic-leaning midterm to flip a U.S. House seat currently held by the other party. Every other major race in Maine broke toward Democrats, including Troy Jackson’s victory over U.S. Sen. Susan Collins and Hannah Pingree’s easy win in the gubernatorial contest.

The outcome would also cap a remarkable political comeback for the 78-year-old former governor, who would rank among the oldest freshmen ever to serve in Congress. He enters a heavily Democratic chamber where a single back-bench member carries limited individual lawmaking power.

Maine has been here before. In 2024, the same congressional district required a ranked-choice runoff after about 3 percent of voters declined to choose either incumbent Democrat Jared Golden or Republican Austin Theriault. Golden ultimately won that contest after a week of tabulation and a subsequent recount. At that time, Golden held a 2,159-vote lead and roughly 48.65 percent of the vote—farther from the majority threshold than LePage is now.

Golden acknowledged LePage’s likely win in a statement Thursday, noting he knows what it takes to win under difficult circumstances. “I also know a thing or two about winning in tough circumstances,” Golden said. “So, I know you have to tip your hat to Paul LePage for winning in the midst of this Blue Tsunami. I stand ready to work with him to ensure the smooth transition that Mainers deserve.”

The ranked-choice tabulation is scheduled to begin Monday morning in Augusta.

Author

Maine News Now

Maine News Now

Related Stories

Westbrook residents work to 'Stuff-A-Bus' with cash and food for families in need
local3 hours ago

Westbrook residents work to 'Stuff-A-Bus' with cash and food for families in need

The Old Town Grinch hands out candy canes and collects food for neighbors in need
local8 hours ago

The Old Town Grinch hands out candy canes and collects food for neighbors in need

17-year-old boy missing in Caribou
local14 hours ago

17-year-old boy missing in Caribou