Mon, Nov 16WeatherBangor, ME
Maine Lottery
Latest draws loading
Maine News Now

Maine is ready to leave the Electoral College. Here’s how it could actually happen.

Maine is ready to leave the Electoral College. Here’s how it could actually happen.
100%

Maine’s four electoral votes are now part of a growing coalition of states that have pledged to award their votes to the candidate who wins the national popular vote, a move that could, if enough jurisdictions join, replace the traditional Electoral College system.

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, which currently includes 19 states plus Washington, D.C., has amassed 222 electoral votes. The agreement is designed to take effect only when the combined total reaches the 270‑vote threshold needed to win the presidency. In the wake of last week’s midterm elections, Democrats captured trifectas in six additional states, giving the party control of both legislative chambers and the governor’s office in those jurisdictions. One of those states, Minnesota, is already a member of the compact; the others together hold 61 electoral votes, a bloc that could push the total past the required 270 if the members choose to activate the pact.

Pat Rosenstiel, a senior consultant for the National Popular Vote group, said the math is already in the coalition’s favor. “I don’t have to squint to see a path to 270 electoral votes before 2028,” he said. “We’ve got more than enough states in play. Frankly, I’m looking getting at 286 (votes) and beyond at this point.”

Maine entered the compact in 2024 after Governor Janet Mills allowed the enabling legislation to become law without signing it, becoming the 17th state to do so. The state’s allocation of electors differs from that of most jurisdictions: two votes go to the statewide popular‑vote winner, while the remaining two are split between the two congressional districts, each awarded to the candidate who wins that district. Nebraska is the only other state that uses a similar split‑district method.

Under the current law, the district‑level electors would remain bound to the outcome of their individual races unless the compact becomes active, at which point they would be required to cast votes for the national popular‑vote winner.

The push to abandon the Electoral College has gained momentum after two presidents in the past quarter‑century—George W. Bush and Donald Trump—won the office despite losing the popular vote. Al Gore received more than half a million votes more than Bush in 2000, and Hillary Clinton amassed nearly three million more votes than Trump in 2016. Public opinion also leans toward change: a July Pew Research Center poll found that 63 percent of voters support abolishing the Electoral College.

The movement is not strictly partisan. Wisconsin’s new governor, David Crowley, declared, “We can do away” with the Electoral College. Pennsylvania’s governor, Josh Shapiro, added on a podcast that “the national popular vote makes sense.” Both leaders are suggesting that their states could be pivotal in reaching the 270‑vote mark.

Nevertheless, the issue has become deeply divided along party lines in many state legislatures. Mark Brewer, chair of the University of Maine’s political science department, argues that the current system “currently benefits Republicans, but it used to benefit Democrats when Democrats controlled the South.” He characterizes the Electoral College as “not a principled thing; it’s a partisan advantage thing,” and warns that “the Electoral College works to benefit Republicans” today.

Legal scholars caution that the compact could face constitutional challenges. Because the Constitution grants states the authority to allocate their electoral votes but also requires congressional consent for interstate agreements, lawsuits could arise claiming violations of the “one person, one vote” principle. Brewer warned, “We could find ourselves in a situation where we’ve got a court challenge to who won a presidential election that we can’t figure out before the new president would have to take the oath of office.”

Opponents in Maine have raised concerns that the compact would undermine the state’s current balance between at‑large and district‑level voting. A bill to withdraw from the compact cleared the House last year but stalled in the Senate, with conservatives arguing that the existing congressional‑district method provides a “best compromise” for representing diverse voter preferences.

Rosenstiel counters that the present system “discourages people from wasting their vote on a third‑party candidate,” and that a national popular vote would “truly be just whomever gets the most votes wins.” He adds, “It has everything to do with putting voters in charge… I believe a conservative Second Amendment Republican like me in a blue state like Minnesota should matter as much as a liberal, progressive Democrat in Oklahoma City.”

The prospect of the compact taking effect before the 2028 election has energized both supporters and skeptics. If the additional 61 electoral votes from the newly Democratic‑controlled states join the existing 222, the coalition would surpass the 270‑vote threshold, effectively rendering the Electoral College obsolete and reshaping how presidential campaigns are conducted. Yet the possibility of future political shifts leading some states to rescind their membership keeps the debate alive. As the nation heads toward the 2026 elections, Maine’s unique electoral arrangement and its participation in the compact place it at the center of a potential seismic change in American presidential politics.

Author

Maine News Now

Maine News Now

Related Stories

Westbrook residents work to 'Stuff-A-Bus' with cash and food for families in need
local3 hours ago

Westbrook residents work to 'Stuff-A-Bus' with cash and food for families in need

The Old Town Grinch hands out candy canes and collects food for neighbors in need
local8 hours ago

The Old Town Grinch hands out candy canes and collects food for neighbors in need

17-year-old boy missing in Caribou
local14 hours ago

17-year-old boy missing in Caribou