Maine deregulated electricity 26 years ago. Time for a rigorous review. | Opinion

Bill Webster of Georgetown is a former superintendent of schools in Lewiston. He was also controller for Hannaford Bros. and owned and operated Haven’s Candies. He is now an active SCORE mentor, providing free mentoring to existing and aspiring entrepreneurs.
Would most Maine residential customers pay 20 cents per kilowatt hour if they knew that a 12-cent option was available? Probably not. Do most Mainers know who supplies their electricity and what their rate is per kilowatt hour?
Most Mainers know who delivers it to them: Central Maine Power or Versant Power, depending upon where you live. These distributors also send you the bill, maintain the power lines and restore service after storms. But the company that actually supplies your electricity is an entirely different business.
I suspect many Mainers couldn’t identify their electricity supplier without searching through their monthly bill. Until recently, I thought I knew mine.
In 1997, Maine enacted legislation restructuring the state’s electricity industry. Beginning in March 2000, consumers could choose among competing electricity suppliers, while utilities such as CMP continued to deliver the electricity. The premise was straightforward: Competition would provide more choices and encourage lower prices.
For customers who didn’t choose a supplier, the state established the Standard Offer, with rates determined through competitive bidding overseen by the Maine Public Utilities Commission.
Advertisement
More than a quarter-century later, it’s worth asking whether that experiment has delivered the promised benefits. Consider my recent experience.
Earlier this summer, I contacted CMP and confirmed that I was receiving electricity through the Standard Offer. My June bill clearly identifies it as my supplier. Imagine my surprise when I discovered that my supplier had subsequently changed to SmartEnergy, at a rate of 20.4 cents per kilowatt-hour, approximately 60% higher than the Standard Offer rate of 12.721 cents. The price difference certainly helps fund the rebates that SmartEnergy offers.
When I contacted SmartEnergy, I was told that my wife had authorized the change during a telephone conversation in May. She recalls responding to a solicitation concerning a rebate but says she never knowingly agreed to change our electricity supplier.
The solicitation itself was intriguing. Prominently displayed were the words, “Please choose a payout option for your rebate.” It also identified us as CMP customers. Was this an offer from our electricity provider, a refund we were entitled to receive, or a marketing promotion designed to attract new customers?
Apparently, we didn’t understand what was being offered.
Whether the record of the phone call establishes that proper authorization was obtained remains to be determined. But the experience illustrates how difficult it can be for consumers to understand the choices they are making.
Advertisement
And there’s more. Like many Mainers, I also participate in a community solar program. That arrangement involves credits against my CMP bill and a separate monthly statement from another company. Between the delivery company, the electricity supplier and the solar program, understanding my household’s electricity costs has become surprisingly complicated.
Does all this competition actually save us money?
According to a January 2026 report presented by Maine’s Office of the Public Advocate, Maine residential customers purchasing electricity from competitive suppliers paid an estimated $156 million more between 2016 and 2024 than they would have paid under the Standard Offer.
The report also found that low-income customers were disproportionately affected. These results were also similar to a study done in Massachusetts. That is a disturbing finding for a system intended to benefit consumers through competition.
Competition can be valuable. Some suppliers offer renewable energy options or fixed-rate contracts that may appeal to certain customers. But competition only works well when consumers understand what they are purchasing and can compare prices and terms.
At a minimum, every electricity supplier should be required to disclose prominently its rate alongside the current Standard Offer, the length of the contract, what happens when it expires and exactly what a consumer is authorizing. Solicitation materials should make unmistakably clear that accepting an incentive may involve changing electricity suppliers.
Perhaps Maine should go further and reconsider whether its current system of residential
electricity competition is delivering sufficient benefits to justify its complexity. I hope this becomes a priority of the next Legislature.
Electricity is an essential service, not a discretionary purchase. Mainers deserve reasonable prices, understandable bills and informed choices. After 26 years of deregulation, shouldn’t we be asking whether the system is working for the people who pay for it?
Copy the Story Link
Tagged: columns




