Look back at Maine’s secondhand shopping scene in photos

From Charity to Thrift: Maine’s Secondhand Shopping Through the Decades
Maine has long prided itself on thriftiness, a habit that stretched back before “vintage” became a buzzword. Even in the 1950s, residents were already turning to community‑run charity shops, church donations, and secondhand stalls to stretch their dollars. The Portland Public Library Special Collections and Archives preserves a handful of photographs that capture this early era of thrift in action, offering a window into the people, places, and purpose that made buying used goods a staple of Maine life.
1953: The Dorcas Welfare Society and a Community Auction
On February 24, 1953, the Dorcas Welfare Society of White Memorial Church in Portland gathered at Bosworth Memorial Hall on Free Street for a public auction. The society’s members—Mrs. Tracy S. Hill, Mrs. Clifford Randall, Mrs. Arthur H. Ricker, and Mrs. Lester H. Elkins—were seen examining clothing, linens, and household items slated for sale. The event was a classic example of the era’s charitable sales, where community members contributed donated goods to support church and social programs. The photograph, captured by an unnamed photographer for the Portland Press Herald, is now housed in the library’s archives.
1967: Volunteers Staging a Thrift Store on Stevens Avenue
Fast forward to August 6, 1967, and a different kind of charitable retailing had taken root in Portland’s downtown. St. Joseph the Provider Thrift Shop, located on Stevens Avenue, was being organized by volunteer clerks Mrs. Clarence Verrill and Mrs. Jack Keeley. While the shop’s inventory was largely secondhand, the volunteers’ careful sorting and staging reflected a growing sense of civic duty and resourcefulness. The Maine Sunday Telegram published a still of the pair reviewing clothing racks, a testament to the grassroots effort that made thrift shopping a local staple. Charles Merrill’s photograph is now part of the Portland Public Library’s Special Collections.
1978: Carpetbagger Trading Co. and Corporate Return Goods
By September 15, 1978, the scope of Maine’s secondhand market had broadened to include corporate return goods. In Portland, shoppers found themselves in the aisles of Carpetbagger Trading Co. on 1120 Forest Avenue, inspecting a diverse array of returned, damaged, or defective items from local companies. The Evening Express documented the scene, showing the public’s curiosity and willingness to repurpose what manufacturers had deemed unsellable. Bill Curran’s snapshot, now archived by the library, underscores how thrift shops had begun to incorporate a wider range of products, extending their reach beyond purely charitable donations.
1980: Goodwill and the Rise of Modern Thrift
A few years later, on April 14, 1980, a stylish shopper perused dresses at Goodwill on 359 Cumberland Avenue, Portland. The Evening Express captured the moment, highlighting how the thrift market had evolved into a place where fashion and function could meet. Goodwill’s presence marked a shift toward a more organized, corporate approach to secondhand retail, while still retaining the community‑focused ethos of earlier charitable sales. Gordon Chibroski’s photo is part of the library’s Special Collections, preserving the image for future generations.
The Legacy of Maine’s Secondhand Culture
These photographs, spanning nearly three decades, illustrate a clear progression in Maine’s approach to secondhand goods. From church‑run auctions to volunteer‑managed thrift shops, to corporate return sales, and finally to the modern Goodwill model, each iteration built upon the last. The common thread has always been a commitment to reuse, a practical mindset, and a sense of community responsibility.
Today, thrift shopping remains a vibrant part of Maine’s retail landscape. The images in the Portland Public Library’s archive not only serve as nostalgic reminders but also as documentation of how thrift culture has shaped—and been shaped by—the state’s values. Whether it is a volunteer sorting donated clothes or a consumer hunting a vintage dress, the spirit of resourcefulness continues to thrive in Maine’s streets.




