Let’s do away with wasteful ranked-choice voting | Letter

Letter Calls for End to Ranked‑Choice Voting After 2nd Congressional District Race
York Harbor, Maine – A letter to the editor published this week in the Press Herald urges the state to scrap Maine’s ranked‑choice voting system after the delayed announcement of the 2nd Congressional District election results.
The letter, written by Marshall Jarvis of York Harbor, criticizes the state’s use of ranked‑choice voting, saying the process “costs money and time” and was “a nightmare for everyone, including voters.” Jarvis points to the election’s late certification as proof that the system is “a charade” that “doesn’t make common sense.”
The 2nd District race
The race, held on November 5, 2026, was between incumbent Representative Paul LePage and challenger Matt Dunlap. LePage ultimately prevailed, securing a lead of 5,400 votes. According to the official recount, the margin was still substantial enough to be decisive, but the state’s ranked‑choice rules required a full tally that included every ballot cast.
Jarvis notes that Maine’s law counts every ballot—valid or blank—when determining whether a candidate has achieved an outright majority. In this case, the inclusion of roughly 6,000 blank ballots lowered the winner’s share below 50 percent, which, under the law, triggers additional “costly additional steps.” The result was a delay in the final certification of the winner, even though Dunlap had conceded the race shortly after the initial count.
Ranked‑choice voting explained
Ranked‑choice voting, also known as instant‑runoff voting, allows voters to rank candidates in order of preference. If no candidate obtains a majority of first‑choice votes, the candidate with the fewest first‑choice votes is eliminated and their ballots are redistributed to the next preferred candidate. This process repeats until a candidate has a majority.
Maine adopted the system in 2018 for federal, state, and local elections. The idea behind the




