Lawsuit seeks to block proposed campground on Sanford’s Sand Pond

A new campground has been approved by Sanford’s planning board, but a lawsuit brought forward by a group of neighbors could bring development to a halt.
Michael Patterson, the developer behind the proposed Sand Pond Shores Camping Resort, said he purchased 115 acres on Sand Pond in 2021 with the intention of creating roughly 40 campsites on a portion of the property.
After years of hurdles, including a citywide moratorium on development to let the city reexamine its ordinances, the planning board approved Patterson’s development at its meeting Wednesday night.
Patterson has plans for about a dozen cabins and 30 RV sites on the east side of Sand Pond. If completed, it would be the second campground on the pond, joining Huttopia Southern Maine.
But four sets of neighbors argue in a lawsuit, filed in June in York County Superior Court, that the campground would violate the area’s common scheme of development and interfere with an easement.
The swath of land was previously owned by Miriam Siddall, who between the 1940s and 1990s sold lots along what is now known as Siddall Road. The four sets of plaintiffs say that those lots carried certain restrictions, including bans on commercial use, advertising and general unsightliness.
Advertisement
Those requirements apply to Patterson’s property, the plaintiffs say, and a campground would violate them. But Patterson says his deed specifically did not include those requirements, because of what he described as an effort by the Siddall family to promote development and get the highest possible return for selling the land. (Siddall died in 2001.)
Two of the sets of plaintiffs — Michael Estes and Richard Razumny — also argue that increased public use of Siddall Road from campground visitors would interfere with their easement and harm their daily lives.
The plaintiffs are asking the court to block Patterson from developing the land. Patterson, in a July response to the lawsuit, denied many of their claims.
Estes said in a phone interview last week that the question of which restrictions apply to whose land is his chief concern.
“How come his deeds don’t have the same restrictions as mine?” he said.
During the public comment period of Wednesday’s planning board meeting, some of the plaintiffs shared their concerns regarding the impact on Sand Pond, as well as the concerns of general disturbance brought about by campers.
Advertisement
“We’re not demons, the people who are opposing this campground,” said plaintiff Guy Chabot, who lives on Sand Pond Road.
“I’m certain if you were in my situation, you probably wouldn’t like having a campground in your backyard either,” Chabot added.
Chabot said Patterson has not approached him or his neighbors to discuss their concerns. Patterson said that was untrue, and that two Zoom meetings involving a third-party consultant took place with several neighbors “long before” the suit was filed.
“I love change,” Holly Bennett, another plaintiff, told the planning board. “What is happening in our neighborhood is not appropriate change.”
The planning board voted 6-1 to approve Patterson’s plan to use the site as a campground. Board member Lawrence Jackson-Rosen abstained because he was unable to attend the site walk, according to Patterson.
The campground received conditional approval, requiring slight design changes like the moving of a septic pump area. Patterson has until February to meet those conditions and hopes he can take care of them as soon as possible to begin the first phase of construction next year.
Despite its approval, the planning board warned Patterson that if the neighbors prevail in their lawsuit, any financial losses will be his to bear.
“I’m not going to wait,” Patterson said about beginning work on the development. “I’m gonna take my chances.”
The suit is pending. Patterson believes the next step will be a mediation session, but a date for that meeting has not been set.
Copy the Story Link
Tagged: camping, development, lawsuits
Abigail is a community reporter for Kennebunk, Kennebunkport, Sanford, and Wells. She recently moved up to Maine from Connecticut after getting her bachelor’s degree in English/Journalism at the University. More by Abigail Driscoll





