Mon, Nov 16WeatherBangor, ME
Maine Lottery
Latest draws loading
Maine News Now

Judge grants injunction to temporarily halt removal of beloved York tree

Judge grants injunction to temporarily halt removal of beloved York tree
100%

York Residents Fight to Keep Honey Locust Tree Standing

York, Maine – A honey locust tree that has become a beloved landmark in York Village Square is now at the center of a legal showdown. A temporary restraining order, issued by Superior Court Judge James Martemucci, has halted the town’s plan to cut the tree—a move that some residents say violates state law and the town’s own climate action plan.

The tree sits on a traffic island beside the Soldiers’ Monument in the heart of York Village. It has been a focal point of a week‑long dispute as town officials work on a long‑awaited revitalization plan that includes reconfiguring the intersection and adding new streetlights.

The Legal Hook

Resident Kiki Tidwell, a former member of York’s climate action committee, filed a lawsuit on Oct. 27 seeking a temporary restraining order. “The town’s decision to remove the tree was a violation of a climate action plan approved by voters in 2022,” Tidwell told reporters. She added, “We could never get the town to hear anything. The town has basically done nothing on the climate action plan.”

Tidwell’s complaint cites a Maine statute that protects public shade trees—those on public right‑of‑ways such as highways and local roads. The law allows trimming or removal only when a public road needs to be altered. She argues that removing the honey locust, which she says helps prevent the area from becoming a “heat island,” breaches that provision. The complaint also points to a York land‑use ordinance that prioritizes the preservation of natural landscapes and alleges an abuse of discretion, claiming the town failed to use available tree‑planting funds to preserve or relocate the tree.

On Oct. 28, Judge Martemucci granted a temporary restraining order that bars crews from touching the tree during ongoing construction. The order remains in effect while the case goes to a hearing scheduled for Friday afternoon, where oral arguments from both sides will be heard.

Town’s Counterargument

Town officials say the removal is part of the 2015 revitalization plan that voters approved. “The removal of the existing tree is part of a project to both alter the town way and improve the safety of the subject intersection,” the town’s response to the lawsuit reads. The plan includes new tree plantings, the officials say, but they contend that the honey locust must be removed to accommodate the intersection’s redesign and improve traffic safety.

Town Manager Peter Joseph, who was quoted in the town’s response, did not answer requests for comment when reached out on Thursday.

Community Reaction

While some residents support the town’s safety‑first approach, others view the honey locust as a treasured green space that has provided shade, beauty, and ecological benefits for decades. Tidwell emphasized the tree’s role in keeping the neighborhood cooler, noting that removing it could leave residents exposed to a potential 10‑15‑degree heat rise while new saplings mature.

“Removing the honey locust could spell decades of unregulated heat for residents in York Village while they wait for saplings to grow,” Tidwell said.

A second resident, James Kences, also filed a request for emergency intervention around the same time, underscoring the depth of local opposition.

What’s Next

The town’s planned removal had been slated for Tuesday or Wednesday (the dates following the Oct. 28 order). Construction crews have been instructed not to touch the tree until the hearing concludes. The Friday courtroom session will decide whether the restraining order stands or is lifted, potentially allowing the tree to be removed or preserved.

Whether York can reconcile its long‑term revitalization goals with the community’s desire to keep a cherished natural feature remains to be seen. As the town waits for a court decision, residents will be watching closely, hoping that the honey locust—and the history it embodies—survives the crossroads of progress and preservation.

Author

Maine News Now

Maine News Now

Related Stories

Westbrook residents work to 'Stuff-A-Bus' with cash and food for families in need
local3 hours ago

Westbrook residents work to 'Stuff-A-Bus' with cash and food for families in need

The Old Town Grinch hands out candy canes and collects food for neighbors in need
local8 hours ago

The Old Town Grinch hands out candy canes and collects food for neighbors in need

17-year-old boy missing in Caribou
local14 hours ago

17-year-old boy missing in Caribou