JONATHAN TURLEY: Midterms empower Democrats to target the Electoral College

After Midterms, Debate Turns to Overhauling Electoral System
The aftermath of the 2022 midterm elections is becoming a debate not just about who holds power, but about the rules that decide how future power is won.
Democratic leaders, activists and scholars are increasingly discussing changes to the architecture of American elections. Chief among the proposals is the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, in which participating states would agree to give their electoral votes to the presidential ticket that wins the national popular vote. The compact has never been tested in court, and Republican critics, including Sen. Deb Fischer of Nebraska, have questioned its legality. Fischer has argued that the Supreme Court has described the Constitution as a “finely wrought” system designed to protect smaller states and prevent majoritarian overreach.
Supporters say the compact could effectively bypass the Electoral College without a formal constitutional amendment. They note that Democrats have won a number of governor’s offices and believe they may have enough states to join the compact.
The push is part of a broader movement that includes calls for Supreme Court expansion, the addition of new states such as Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico, and changes to Senate rules. President Gavin Newsom has expressed openness to packing the Supreme Court and has called the Electoral College system “perverted,” according to commentary accompanying the midterm coverage. Newsom’s remarks have made him a focal point in the debate.
In his book “Rage and the Republic,” legal scholar Jonathan Turley described a long-running effort by liberal academics and commentators to consider major constitutional changes. He cited Harvard professor Michael Klarman, who reportedly outlined a plan to reshape the political system so Republicans could not win future presidential elections. Klarman warned that the Supreme Court could strike down such changes and said the court would need to be expanded in advance.
Turley said Democrats who won elections on Election Day were not waiting to see whether they could win again. They were trying to guarantee future control. He argued that the party likely lacks a veto-proof Senate majority and would need a president willing to support major changes.
Turley has also written about the dangers of replacing the Electoral College. He said he once criticized the institution for allowing a candidate who won the popular vote to lose the presidency, but he still believes a president elected without a majority of the public is deeply problematic. He said he does not believe the time is right for sweeping reforms, and that the push for direct democracy may threaten constitutional traditions.
“The Supreme Court could strike down everything I just described,” Turley said.
Turley has argued that the Framers opposed the kind of direct democratic measures now being discussed. He cited Benjamin Rush’s warning that democracies could become “mobocracies.” He said the current proposals risk reviving concerns that the founders had about majority rule without protections.
The debate has alarmed Republicans and constitutional scholars. Fischer said the left’s efforts against the Senate and the Supreme Court put the republic at risk. She said the National Popular Vote Compact was designed to avoid the constitutional amendment process because its advocates knew how difficult such a change would be.
The source story also noted that Democrats view the GOP’s midterm losses as potentially opening a new window. Republicans lost about 46 House seats, a figure that was smaller than losses endured by Democrats under presidents such as Franklin Delano Roosevelt, Barack Obama, Harry Truman and Bill Clinton. Some Democrats and pundits said the party should use the moment to pursue long-discussed changes.
Others caution that the proposals are not simply policy disagreements. They involve altering institutions that have been central to American governance for centuries.
For now, the discussion is continuing. After the midterms, the fight over elections has shifted from ballot-box battles to debates over the rules themselves. Whether framed as reform, defense or revolution, the question remains: how much should the system be changed before the next national election?

