Jewish leaders in Michigan prepare to work with Abdul El-Sayed despite lingering concerns

Jewish Leaders Weigh In on Michigan’s Historic Senate Win
Detroit – Democratic Sen.‑elect Abdul El‑Sayed’s victory over former U.S. Rep. Mike Rogers on Tuesday marked a historic moment for Michigan: he will become the first Muslim elected to the U.S. Senate. The announcement has sparked a range of responses from Jewish leaders and community groups, some welcoming the milestone, others voicing concern over El‑Sayed’s record on Israel and his controversial remarks.
The election results drew cheers from the Jewish Federation of Detroit, whose CEO, Steven Ingber, told Fox News Digital that “we congratulate all the winners, and we will work with all the winners.” Ingber explained that the Federation, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, cannot endorse candidates but can collaborate with any elected official. “The Jewish voice and Jewish vote is not monolithic,” he said. “We have people who voted on every side of the aisle on all the races up and down the ballot. The beauty of being a 501(c)(3) is we don’t get to take an opinion and we just get to work with whoever then is elected.”
Ingber framed the reaction as part of the “beauty of our system,” emphasizing unity. “There’ll be an election again in two years,” he said. “People were upset then, people were happy then. I think that’s the beauty of our system right now is — America will go on.”
While some Jewish Democrats expressed optimism that El‑Sayed could be a bridge, others have expressed lingering reservations. A prominent voice in that conversation is Democratic strategist Julian Epstein. In a Fox News Digital interview, Epstein said that Democrats have been inconsistent in opposing bigotry, especially when Jews are targets. “If you believe in civil rights, you don’t do it for one group, but not for another,” he warned. “You don’t just capitulate for one group.” Epstein also warned of a potential shift in the Jewish electorate. “I think there’s no question that Jewish voters are going to start leaving the Democratic Party,” he said. “They should. I mean, why would you stick with a party that openly tolerates hate directed at you?”
El‑Sayed’s own remarks during the campaign have fueled the debate. After the March 12, 2026 attack on Temple Israel in West Bloomfield, the FBI reported that a driver, Ayman Mohamad Ghazali, crashed a truck filled with fireworks and flammable liquid into the synagogue. The driver was killed when he fired a self‑inflicted gunshot in a shoot‑out with synagogue security. In the wake of the incident, El‑Sayed said, “Hurt people, hurt people,” a comment that many in the Jewish community interpreted as insensitive or even excusing violence. He later apologized, saying his words “might have been misconstrued to be justifying something I did not intend to justify.”
The comment, coupled with El‑Sayed’s history of “anti‑Israel rhetoric” and ties to “controversial figures,” has prompted scrutiny. The American Jewish Committee’s Detroit chapter released a statement acknowledging the historic nature of El‑Sayed’s election but expressing concern about his “continued anti‑Israel rhetoric that alienates countless Jewish Michiganders and other supporters of the State of Israel, and endangers American Jews.” The AJC said: “As a U.S. Senator, El‑Sayed will have the responsibility to represent all Michiganders. The Senator‑elect proclaimed that America is ‘big enough for all of us,’ but his obsessive hostility toward Israel yet again in his victory speech told many Jewish Michiganders and countless others who support Israel that they are not included.”
Ingber, who has been a vocal advocate against anti‑Jewish hate, emphasized that antisemitism is not confined to one side of the political spectrum. “We have antisemitism coming at us from both sides, from the far‑left, from the far‑right,” he said. “Neither is better, neither is worse. Antisemitism isn’t a Jewish problem, it’s an American problem.” He urged the Jewish community not to retreat from public Jewish life due to rising antisemitism or political divisions. “Antisemitism and people who don’t want us to succeed in life are not going to stop us from being who we are,” Ingber said.
El‑Sayed’s campaign has not yet responded to Fox News Digital’s request for comment. The Senator‑elect’s victory is expected to be announced formally in Detroit early next week, and he will take his oath of office in the Senate in Washington, D.C. in the coming weeks.
For Michigan’s Jewish community, the win presents a complex mix of pride in a historic first and anxiety over a record that some see as at odds with their interests. As the new Senator begins to navigate his role, the community’s leaders remain ready to engage, hoping that the shared commitment to civil rights and pluralism can bridge divides.

