Israeli president taps Netanyahu rival to form government as coalition battle looms

Israeli President Herzog Names Opposition Leader Gadi Eisenkot to Form New Government
Tel Aviv, Nov. 7 – In a move that could end long‑running Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s tenure, Israeli President Isaac Herzog announced today that opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot will be given the first chance to assemble Israel’s next cabinet. The formal presentation of Herzog’s mandate is scheduled for Sunday, Nov. 8, at 5 p.m. Israeli time, and Eisenkot will have 28 days to build a coalition—extendable by 14 more days if necessary.
The Decision
Herzog’s decision follows two days of consultations with members of the newly elected Knesset. In a statement on Thursday, Herzog said that “the results of the consultations may appear clear,” yet he warned that “competing political demands and vetoes have left the prospects for forming a government uncertain.” The consultations had yielded endorsements from 67 of the 120 Knesset seats: 46 backing Netanyahu, 21 for Eisenkot, and seven from the ultra‑Orthodox United Torah Judaism party who declined to recommend either candidate. Seven seats from the Shas party had supported Netanyahu, and the rest of the Parliament’s members had not yet taken a position.
The Political Landscape
Israel’s most recent election on Oct. 27 produced a fragmented parliament. Likud, led by Netanyahu, won 27 seats, and its broader coalition achieved 53 seats. A four‑party bloc opposing Netanyahu secured 48 seats. Eisenkot’s endorsements also included two Arab‑led parties—the Joint List and Ra’am—which together hold 19 seats. Their support presents a challenge, as some prospective coalition partners have ruled out reliance on Arab parties for a governing majority.
Eisenkot’s Plan
In a statement issued Friday, Eisenkot outlined the framework for what he calls a “National Emergency Government.” He said the new cabinet would “initially be based on the four parties committed to replacing Netanyahu” while keeping the door open for additional lawmakers. His vision hinges on four principles: recognition of Israel as a Jewish and democratic state; adherence to the values of the Declaration of Independence; universal military, national, or civilian service; and a commitment to designate Hamas as a terrorist organization and dismantle its military and governance structures.
Eisenkot described the current situation as “a genuine, tangible and dangerous national emergency” and warned that continued instability could erode security and diplomatic standing. “Negotiations with my political partners have already produced significant progress, and further talks are underway,” he added.
A Shift on Conscription
The most significant development in coalition negotiations came with a statement from Avigdor Lieberman, leader of the secular nationalist Yisrael Beitenu party. In a post on X, Lieberman said he was now willing to compromise on military conscription for ultra‑Orthodox Jews—a point that has long blocked cooperation with religious parties. He argued that preventing another election and ending Netanyahu’s rule would require difficult political compromises, and he identified three conditions: ending the Netanyahu era, avoiding a repeat election, and refusing to form a government dependent on the abstention of the Joint List and Ra’am.
Lieberman’s openness to dialogue could pave the way for talks with United Torah Judaism, whose seven lawmakers had withheld endorsement from Netanyahu. United Torah Judaism leader Yaakov Asher welcomed Lieberman’s flexibility but said no concrete proposal had yet been presented, and any agreement would need approval from the party’s religious leadership.
Remaining Challenges
Even if United Torah Judaism were brought into the coalition, Eisenkot would still fall short of the 61 seats required for an outright majority, as the religious Shas party—holding six seats—has recommended Netanyahu. Eisenkot’s allies have discussed forming a minority government that would rely on abstentions from parties outside the coalition, but Lieberman rejected any plan that depends on Arab parties for its stability.
The core issue remains: while a majority of lawmakers recommended Eisenkot to form the next government, the parties have not agreed on the composition of that government. Disagreements over the draft military service law, the role of Arab lawmakers, and the allocation of cabinet posts keep the negotiation process tense.
Current Status
Netanyahu continues as caretaker prime minister while coalition talks unfold. He has challenged aspects of the election results, citing alleged irregularities in the Arab‑led parties’ performance, though Israel’s Central Elections Committee has confirmed the integrity of the vote. The next few weeks will determine whether Eisenkot can transform his parliamentary endorsement into a functioning cabinet, or whether Israel may face another election amid continued political deadlock.

