Mon, Nov 16WeatherBangor, ME
Maine Lottery
Latest draws loading
Maine News Now

Inside a rancher family's clash with gov't that could have ripple effect right to SCOTUS: ‘Existential threat’

Inside a rancher family's clash with gov't that could have ripple effect right to SCOTUS: ‘Existential threat’
100%

Washington Ranchers Battle Ecological Fines, Claiming Their Survival Depends on Jury Trial

Wade and Teresa King, owners of King Ranch in Grant and Douglas counties, say they are facing an “existential threat” after the Washington State Department of Ecology fined the family $267,540 last year for alleged damage to wetlands. The ranchers argue that the disputed areas are stock‑water ponds they have used for livestock for decades, not regulated wetlands, and they contend that the fine and required restoration orders are unreasonable and could set a precedent that affects ranchers across the nation.

The Fine and the Alleged Damage

In 2023, the Department of Ecology issued a penalty to the Kings for allegedly creating or modifying 23 natural wetlands by excavating, recontouring, and filling in the land to form ponds. According to the agency, the owners damaged 6.37 acres of naturally occurring wetlands. “Ecology inspectors made site visits to these damaged areas where possible, but also used satellite imagery, aerial images dating from as far back as 1949, and other records to determine that the Kings had damaged 6.37 acres of naturally occurring wetlands by excavating, recontouring, and putting fill in them,” the department said in a statement on its website. It also ordered the Kings to restore 34 areas in total—11 additional sites in Douglas County last year, many of which sit on state land.

The Kings maintain that the ponds were built for livestock and have existed on the ranch for generations. They point to a lack of evidence that the sites were wetlands before the construction of the ponds, arguing that the Department’s characterization is incorrect. “We want clean water,” Wade said. “Why would we pollute or cause damage to the land or the water that we rely on in our livelihood? We’re generational. Why would we do something to harm ourselves that way and harm the environment?”

Legal Battle Begins

Shortly after the fine, the Kings began a legal challenge. The Department’s regulations require owners to first resolve disputes through the Pollution Control Hearings Board (PCHB), an administrative panel that does not provide a jury trial. In March, the Kings filed a separate lawsuit in Grant County Superior Court, arguing that the case should not be decided by the PCHB and that doing so would violate their right to a jury trial under the Seventh Amendment.

A judge dismissed the suit, ruling that the Kings must first complete the administrative process with the PCHB. The Kings appealed, and in September the Washington Court of Appeals paused the PCHB proceedings while it considered whether the ranchers were entitled to a jury trial. “It’s all under the executive branch, and they very rarely go with the property owner,” Wade explained. “They almost always side with the agencies and it’s just not a fair trial for appellants like us.”

The PCHB has declined to comment on the pending case.

The Stakes

The Kings say that their financial stability—and the rights of other ranchers—are on the line. “Losing this fight would be an existential threat,” Wade told Fox News Digital. “I don’t know how we would recover from that, to be honest with you.” Teresa echoed the sentiment, warning that the restoration orders would be “unachievable” because the areas were never wetlands in the first place. “How do we as ranchers turn these into wetlands and comply with everything that Ecology wants us to?” she asked. “It’ll be unachievable and it would just spin us in the ground financially.”

The costs of compliance are estimated at more than $3.7 million, according to the Kings’ attorneys. The family has runched in Grant and Douglas counties since the 1950s, and multiple generations—including a fourth, fifth, and sixth—work on the property. Teresa said, “We just want to be left alone.” She added, “It’s not just us. We are defending every rancher in the state of Washington’s exempt livestock water rights.”

Potential National Implications

Oliver Dunford, a senior attorney at the Pacific Legal Foundation representing the Kings, said the ranchers are prepared to petition the U.S. Supreme Court if they are unsuccessful in Washington. He told Fox News Digital, “We have to ask them one question: to rule that the Seventh Amendment does apply against the states, and then to argue that the Kings should have had a jury trial under the Seventh Amendment.” Dunford explained that a Supreme Court decision in the case could “have ripple effects across other states,” potentially preventing state agencies from issuing fines without allowing property owners a chance to defend themselves before a jury.

The Department of Ecology has defended the fine, citing evidence from satellite imagery and historic aerial photographs. The agency also stated it “repeatedly sought to resolve concerns about the damage” but that the Kings had refused to cooperate. The Kings have denied any cooperation refusal, insisting that they have always protected and cared for the land.

Broader Context

This dispute underscores a broader tension between state environmental regulations and agricultural interests. While the Department’s mandate is to protect wetlands, the Kings argue that the agency’s interpretation of their stock‑water ponds as wetlands imposes undue burdens. The case could set a precedent for how wetlands are defined and enforced, influencing ranchers and landowners throughout the United States.

The Kings’ fight is ongoing. The PCHB proceedings remain on hold pending the outcome of the appellate review. If the case reaches the Supreme Court, it could reshape the balance between environmental oversight and property rights in Washington and potentially across the country. For now, the ranchers continue to defend their legacy and livelihoods, hoping that the judicial system will recognize their right to a jury trial and the legitimacy of their long‑standing ranching operations.

Author

Maine News Now

Maine News Now

Related Stories

49ers offense puts up over 580 yards against a bad Cowboys defense behind a Christian McCaffrey masterclass
NATIONALnational5 hours ago

49ers offense puts up over 580 yards against a bad Cowboys defense behind a Christian McCaffrey masterclass

Pete Buttigieg breaks with Democrats on student loan handouts, admits party ‘overtorqued’ on issue
NATIONALnational5 hours ago

Pete Buttigieg breaks with Democrats on student loan handouts, admits party ‘overtorqued’ on issue

Lane Kiffin blames LSU's $40+ million roster after loss to Texas: 'we'll have better rosters’
NATIONALnational6 hours ago

Lane Kiffin blames LSU's $40+ million roster after loss to Texas: 'we'll have better rosters’