Mon, Nov 16WeatherBangor, ME
Maine Lottery
Latest draws loading
Maine News Now

Gorham resident sues town over zoning change that could allow quarry expansion

Gorham resident sues town over zoning change that could allow quarry expansion
100%

Gorham Resident Files Lawsuit Over Quarry Expansion Zoning Change

A resident of Gorham has sued the town after a recent zoning decision that would let Shaw Brothers Construction expand the Brickyard Quarry closer to residential neighborhoods. John Wise, a homeowner whose property borders the quarry, filed the suit in Cumberland County Superior Court this week, arguing that the town council’s 4‑to‑3 vote to rezone 14 acres from “urban residential expansion” to “industrial” violated the town’s comprehensive plan.

The change would allow the company to add about 6 acres to the roughly 40‑acre quarry, extending its operating life from an estimated 50 years to 60. It would also move the quarry’s front edge nearer to Queen Street, a main thoroughfare that serves many of the town’s 2,251 homes within a two‑mile radius.

“We’re concerned that this proposal is moving forward toward approval while certain questions remain unanswered and studies unsubmitted,” said Emily Hamblen, whose family’s land abuts the quarry property. “It’s a beautiful place, and it’s taking this quarry process, and it wants to bring it closer to where people are.”

Zoning Decision and Legal Challenges

The town council’s September vote followed a public hearing held in early December, during which the company’s application was held up for missing information. Shaw Brothers Construction said it has an updated noise study and an air‑quality review, but it still needs a permit from the Maine Department of Environmental Protection.

Wise’s lawsuit contends that the zoning shift contravenes the 2016 comprehensive plan, which designates the 14 acres as a “Village Expansion” zone for housing. “It was not meant for industrial activity,” Wise’s legal representative, Andre James Hungerford, said. “No one has studied the effects of the particulates of the fugitive dust.”

The complaint also alleges that the council’s decision “is illegal” because it ignores the future land‑use plan and conflicts with the town’s growth objectives. It claims the change would “allow mining on that land that is out of harmony with town goals.”

Shaw Brothers Construction joined the lawsuit as an interested party, but officials for both the town and the company declined to comment. The town’s planning board members, David Walsh and William Benson, had asked for data on silica dust content, health impacts, and inspection frequency during the hearing. “We want to know more about how often the DEP and the town inspect the facility,” said Benson.

Company Position

Dan Shaw, co‑owner of Shaw Brothers, says the company has promptly addressed neighbors’ dust and blast complaints. “Residents are concerned for no reason, and expansion will not worsen conditions,” Shaw told the board. He added that the company has not heard similar issues from neighbors of its other quarries across Maine.

Lee Pratt, the company’s general manager, explained that it coordinates with the blasting contractor ahead of time if weather conditions could increase noise or pressure. “We proceed with blasts regardless when those conditions cannot be predicted,” Pratt said. “Most of the visible material that rises after a blast is gas that dissipates, rather than particles that can be carried by the wind to residents’ homes.”

The company says the expansion would not introduce new activities; once the quarry’s rock is exhausted, it will continue crushing at the site.

Regulatory Oversight

The Maine Department of Environmental Protection last inspected the quarry in June 2023, according to Deputy Commissioner and Communications Director David Madore. “The most recent DEP air inspection of the facility was in June 2023,” Madore said in July.

During the hearing, the board also discussed the lack of weather‑condition regulations for blasting, a concern raised by Pete Bennett of Maine Drilling and Blasting. “There are no regulations on the weather conditions that his company can blast in,” Bennett said. Walsh requested more information on restrictions elsewhere.

Town’s Response and Future Plans

In September, the Gorham Town Council approved $35,000 of tax‑increment financing to hire a consultant to review the strength of the town’s quarry ordinances and recommend changes. Staff will meet next week to finalize the scope of work and begin the review. “The consultant’s findings will not apply to the existing Brickyard Quarry or to the expansion if it is approved before ordinance changes go into effect,” said Town Manager Ephrem Paraschak.

Many residents hope the review will delay the expansion until all environmental and community concerns are addressed. “I’m concerned about moving forward while questions remain,” said Hamblen again. “It’s a beautiful place, and we don’t want to see the quarry process encroach further.”

Next Steps

The lawsuit is pending in Cumberland County Superior Court. While the town moves to evaluate its regulations, Shaw Brothers Construction will need to secure a DEP permit before proceeding with the expansion. The outcome of the court case could set a precedent for future quarry operations in the region.

The town’s planning board remains poised

Author

Maine News Now

Maine News Now

Related Stories

Westbrook residents work to 'Stuff-A-Bus' with cash and food for families in need
local3 hours ago

Westbrook residents work to 'Stuff-A-Bus' with cash and food for families in need

The Old Town Grinch hands out candy canes and collects food for neighbors in need
local8 hours ago

The Old Town Grinch hands out candy canes and collects food for neighbors in need

17-year-old boy missing in Caribou
local14 hours ago

17-year-old boy missing in Caribou