Former Brunswick police officer accused of excessive force, false arrest

Brunswick Officer Faces Lawsuit Over Alleged Assault of Minor During 2025 Traffic Stop
A former Brunswick police officer, 27, is being sued by a former 17‑year‑old who was allegedly assaulted during a traffic stop last December. The lawsuit, filed in federal court on Friday, names Officer Nathan Day, another unnamed officer, and the Town of Brunswick as defendants.
The Incident
According to the complaint, the traffic stop occurred in the parking lot of the Cook’s Corner shopping plaza. Officers had pulled over the teenage girl’s boyfriend, and the girl was following in a separate vehicle. When the officers ordered the boy’s vehicle to stop, Day ordered the girl out of her car and, the complaint says, “used excessive and unprovoked force.” The girl was allegedly slammed so hard that her head hit the car and the ground, rendering her unconscious. She was then handcuffed, transported to a hospital in restraints, and later arrested for traffic violations that were dismissed in September.
The lawsuit claims Day and the unnamed officer falsely arrested the girl, alleging she had committed a crime. The girl suffered a head wound that required staples, a concussion, fractures in her foot, and seizures. She is now an adult, and her name is included in the lawsuit, though the Press Herald has not named the victim in its reporting.
Legal Proceedings
Day was charged with a Class D assault in March. He waived arraignment and pleaded not guilty to the misdemeanor charge. Police Chief Scott Stewart confirmed that Day was no longer with the Brunswick Police Department Saturday. The lawsuit seeks compensatory and punitive damages, attorney’s fees, and a jury trial.
Day’s attorney, Marc Beaudoin, rejected the allegations. In a statement emailed to the Press Herald, Beaudoin said that Day had asked the girl to come over to him multiple times in order to issue a ticket for cellphone use while driving. When she refused, he began to handcuff her. Beaudoin further claimed the teenager “kicked him in the knee” as she tried to move away. He stated, “Day did not use any excessive force” and that the injuries were “inadvertent and due to her own refusal to comply.”
Prior Disciplinary History
The lawsuit also cites three prior disciplinary actions against Day. Records obtained by the Press Herald show that Day was formally disciplined in September 2023, July 2025, and August 2025. The most recent incident involved an August 2025 disciplinary action after Day tackled a suspect, requiring remedial training. Earlier reports involved Day driving a police cruiser and pursuing another vehicle in ways that violated departmental policy.
Town’s Role
The complaint accuses the Town of Brunswick of failing to properly discipline Day, allowing him to remain on the force despite repeated violations of constitutional rights and departmental regulations. Attorneys for the plaintiff said in a joint statement, “While Nathan Day’s actions last December are at the heart of this suit, this case is also about the lack of discipline in the Town of Brunswick’s police department, which allowed Mr. Day to stay on the force despite repeated flouting of the Constitution and departmental regulations.”
Current Status
The federal lawsuit is the first civil action against Day, who has already faced criminal charges. The case remains pending, with both sides preparing for a possible trial. The outcome could have broader implications for how small-town police departments handle officer misconduct and disciplinary procedures.
Sources: Press releases from the Brunswick Police Department, statements from Day’s attorney Marc Beaudoin, and the federal lawsuit filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Maine.



