ESPN's Monica McNutt and Ryan Clark claim Caitlin Clark has brought 'negativity' to the WNBA
Monica McNutt Criticizes Caitlin Clark on “The Pivot” Podcast
June 2025 – In a recent episode of Ryan Clark’s podcast, “The Pivot,” former ESPN personality Monica McNutt discussed the rising star of the Women’s National Basketball Association (WNBA), Caitlin Clark, and the league’s growing popularity. McNutt’s comments drew attention for their focus on Clark’s performance, her fan base and alleged race‑based criticism.
Podcast appearance
The episode, streamed on the podcast’s official channel in late May, featured McNutt as a guest. Clark’s name appeared frequently as the discussion turned to her impact on the league’s viewership and media coverage. McNutt, who has previously written about the WNBA for ESPN, used the platform to voice her opinions on Clark’s playing style, her handling of controversy, and the way her name is sometimes used in broader social conversations.
McNutt’s statements
During the discussion, McNutt made several remarks that were seen by many as controversial:
“If this was the other way around, oh Lord, you can imagine how the conversation would have gone,” she said after describing a 2025 flagrant foul by Clark on Angel Reese. The comment was interpreted by listeners as a reference to a potential backlash if the roles were reversed.
“You need to respect the humanity of these women,” McNutt added while addressing the broader discourse around the incident, noting that Reese had received “racist comments” and that Clark was often portrayed as the victim.
When asked how Clark’s presence has affected the WNBA, McNutt replied, “I think you can certainly celebrate the basketball and the growth, and then you just kind of gotta be honest about the rest of it.” She also said, “I think the exit interviews when Indiana wrapped up the season left some folks scratching their heads.”
McNutt also commented on the league’s standings: “My rookie of the year is going to go based on the standings. And the Sky right now are in the playoffs. So, you'd have to give the nod in my mind to Angel Reese.” She later added, “I think the exit interviews when Indiana wrapped up the season left some folks scratching their heads.”
She expressed doubt about Clark’s stance on racism, saying, “To Caitlin Clark’s credit, she did call out the things that she does not support, which I have not heard vocally from her many a time.” McNutt concluded the segment by stating, “I can hold a little bit of grace for a girl from the Midwest,” in reference to Clark’s background.
Caitlin Clark’s responses
Clark has addressed allegations of racism and fan backlash in several interviews. In her exit interview after the 2024 season, she said:
“I think as far as people that have used me to demonstrate racist rhetoric or hate or discrimination, that’s not something I stand for.”
“Anytime I see something like that, it makes me upset, makes me sad, makes me really disappointed because that’s not who I am.”
In a 2024 interview regarding her name being used to push political or racial agendas, Clark added, “I think it’s disappointing… People should not be using my name to push those agendas.”
These statements have been referenced in the podcast to counter McNutt’s comments.
Context: Clark’s career and the league’s growth
Caitlin Clark, a 24‑year‑old guard for the Indiana Fever, became the first player in WNBA history to lead the league in points and assists during a rookie season. She has drawn record attendance, increased television ratings, and brought national attention to the WNBA. Critics and supporters alike have debated whether the increased scrutiny on Clark’s actions off‑court is warranted.
The 2025 flagrant foul incident involving Angel Reese prompted widespread discussion about fan reactions and media framing. McNutt’s remarks on the podcast echoed concerns that the conversation could be skewed based on race or the identity of the players involved.
Reactions
While the episode was praised by some listeners for bringing the conversation about race, representation and media coverage in the WNBA to the forefront, others criticized McNutt’s tone and perceived bias. Several WNBA players, including Angel Reese and Kelsey Mitchell, have previously commented on the importance of separating athletic performance from political or racial narratives. Clark’s own statements on the subject have been cited by supporters as evidence of her commitment to addressing racism.
The episode also sparked discussion on the role of former broadcasters in shaping public perception of current athletes. McNutt’s previous work with ESPN and her recent appearances on other sports shows have positioned her as a frequent commentator on WNBA topics, but her recent remarks have led to calls for more nuanced coverage.
Looking forward
The conversation surrounding Caitlin Clark’s career and the broader cultural impact of the WNBA continues to evolve. McNutt’s comments on “The Pivot” serve as a reminder of the complexities that athletes face when their athletic achievements intersect with social issues. As the league celebrates increased viewership and fan engagement, stakeholders—including broadcasters, players, and fans—are calling for balanced discussions that focus on both athletic excellence and the responsible handling of broader cultural conversations.