Mon, Nov 16WeatherBangor, ME
Maine Lottery
Latest draws loading
Maine News Now

California DA says Gavin Newsom's 'cruel' death row clemency stabs crime victims 'in the heart'

California DA says Gavin Newsom's 'cruel' death row clemency stabs crime victims 'in the heart'
100%

California Governor Announces Plan to Remove All 548 Death Sentences, Provoking Strong Reactions from Prosecutors and Victims’ Families

CALIFORNIA – In a move that has shocked the state’s justice community, Gov. Gavin Newsom announced on November 5 a plan to commute the death sentences of every inmate on California’s death row to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. The announcement, made in a public letter to Californians, has sparked sharp criticism from Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer, who called the decision “immoral” and an act that “stabs in the heart” of victims and their families.

The Governor’s Rationale

In the letter, Newsom explained that the death penalty “is incompatible with California’s values” and that the system is “inherently unfair.” He cited the risk of executing innocent people and argued that the state’s record of wrongful convictions and unequal application of the death penalty made the policy untenable. “This decision is among the most difficult of my career, not because I doubt its necessity for our state, but because I know its announcement may surface excruciating memories for victims’ families,” Newsom wrote.

The plan would replace each death sentence with a life term that carries no possibility of parole. Newsom’s office insists the commutations would not create a path for release, countering concerns that changes to parole law could eventually open a door for inmates to seek freedom.

Prosecutorial Backlash

DA Todd Spitzer, who has overseen some of the most high‑profile death‑penalty cases in the state, condemned the move in a Fox News interview. “It literally stabbed in the heart many victims who have suffered through an already‑unjust justice system in California that already revictimizes victims over and over and over,” he said. Spitzer added that converting death sentences to life without parole could, in his view, “allow convicted killers to seek release if future changes to state law create a pathway to parole or resentencing.” He described Newsom’s action as “callous,” “calculated,” “mean,” “ugly,” and “ill‑spirited.”

Spitzer also warned of a possible legal battle. Under the California Constitution, inmates convicted of a felony on two or more occasions require a recommendation from the California Supreme Court—four justices must concur—for a commutation to take effect. He said the governor’s plan faces a “legal hurdle for hundreds of inmates” and that the decision has “already revictimized families by causing additional suffering after years of legal proceedings.”

Victims’ Families Respond

The announcement has drawn a chorus of grief and anger from families of victims whose loved ones were killed by the inmates Newsom is set to commute. Marc Klaas, whose 12‑year‑old daughter Polly was murdered in 1993 by Richard Allen Davis, said the decision is “the most painful thing I’ve ever felt.” Klaas, who has long opposed the death penalty, has repeatedly called for harsher punishment for violent offenders.

Other victims’ relatives have echoed his sentiments. The families of those who survived or lost loved ones to serial killers such as Charles Ng and Cary Stayner—a convicted murderer of four people near Yosemite National Park—have expressed disbelief that the governor would remove the possibility of execution for those who have already served decades in prison.

Notable Inmates

The list of inmates slated for commutation includes a range of notorious criminals:

  • Richard Allen Davis – Convicted of the 1993 murder of 12‑year‑old Polly Klaas, sentenced to death in 1996, with the California Supreme Court upholding his sentence in 2009.
  • Charles Ng – Convicted of 11 murders in the Sierra Nevada foothills; one of the state’s most infamous serial killers.
  • Cary Stayner – Convicted of murdering four people near Yosemite National Park in 1999; sentenced to death for three of those murders.

The commutations would affect all 548 inmates currently on death row, a figure that includes those convicted of a wide array of violent crimes.

Legal and Policy Implications

The governor’s plan is not just a policy shift; it raises a complex legal question. The California Constitution requires the California Supreme Court to approve any commutation involving inmates who have been convicted of more than one felony. For those cases, at least four justices must concur on a recommendation. Newsom’s office has indicated that the necessary approvals are in the process, but the legal requirement remains a potential bottleneck.

Some analysts worry that the shift could be viewed as a “walk out of prison” if future legislative changes open a parole path for life‑without‑parole inmates. Newsom’s office maintains that the commutations will not create such a pathway and that inmates will remain incarcerated for the rest of their lives.

State’s Stance on the Death Penalty

The decision comes amid a broader debate about the death penalty in California. While the state’s legislature has long been divided over the issue, Newsom’s action marks the most sweeping change in decades. The governor’s letter acknowledges the “emotional toll on grieving families” but frames the move as a moral imperative: “I cannot sleep at night. I should never sleep at night with the revictimization that I have caused to these poor victims who have suffered irreparable harm.”

Looking Ahead

Newsom’s plan has already generated a flurry of legal filings and public statements. The state’s prosecutors, represented by the California State Bar’s Criminal Law Section, have indicated that they will challenge the commutations in court. Victims’ families, too, have signaled intentions to pursue legal recourse, arguing that the change infringes on the rights of the bereaved and undermines the finality of justice.

The state’s Department of Corrections has yet to release a timetable for when the commutations will take effect, and the California Supreme Court has not yet issued its required recommendations. The next few weeks will likely see a flurry of court filings, public hearings, and possibly a statewide debate over whether California should maintain its death penalty or move further toward abolition.

As the legal and moral implications of Gov. Newsom’s decision continue to unfold, the story will remain a focal point for advocacy groups, law enforcement officials, victims’ families, and the broader public grappling with questions of justice, safety, and the role of state‑sanctioned punishment.

Author

Maine News Now

Maine News Now

Related Stories

49ers offense puts up over 580 yards against a bad Cowboys defense behind a Christian McCaffrey masterclass
NATIONALnational5 hours ago

49ers offense puts up over 580 yards against a bad Cowboys defense behind a Christian McCaffrey masterclass

Pete Buttigieg breaks with Democrats on student loan handouts, admits party ‘overtorqued’ on issue
NATIONALnational5 hours ago

Pete Buttigieg breaks with Democrats on student loan handouts, admits party ‘overtorqued’ on issue

Lane Kiffin blames LSU's $40+ million roster after loss to Texas: 'we'll have better rosters’
NATIONALnational6 hours ago

Lane Kiffin blames LSU's $40+ million roster after loss to Texas: 'we'll have better rosters’