Mon, Nov 16WeatherBangor, ME
Maine Lottery
Latest draws loading
Maine News Now

Brunswick police officer accused of excessive force, false arrest

Brunswick police officer accused of excessive force, false arrest
100%

BRUNSWICK — A federal lawsuit filed Friday accuses a Brunswick police officer of using excessive force against a teenager during a traffic stop last December, then falsely arresting her, while alleging the town ignored a pattern of misconduct that should have removed him from patrol years earlier.

The complaint, lodged in U.S. District Court, names Officer Nathan Day, 27, a second unidentified officer, and the Town of Brunswick as defendants. It seeks compensatory and punitive damages, attorney's fees, and a jury trial on behalf of a young woman who was 17 at the time of the Dec. 18, 2025, encounter in the Cook's Corner shopping plaza parking lot. Now an adult, she is identified by name in the court filing, though Maine News Now is withholding it consistent with policy regarding alleged victims.

According to the lawsuit, the teenager had been following her boyfriend in a separate vehicle as they drove to a body shop to repair a broken taillight on his car. When officers pulled her boyfriend over, she waited across the lot. The filing alleges Day ordered her out of her vehicle without justification, then slammed her head into her car and onto the pavement, rendering her unconscious.

She was arrested on traffic violations that were dismissed in September. Transported to the hospital in handcuffs, she received staples for a head wound and was diagnosed with a concussion, foot fractures, and seizures, the complaint states.

Day was placed on administrative leave on Dec. 19, 2025, the day after the incident, Police Chief Scott Stewart confirmed. In March, the Cumberland County District Attorney's Office charged Day with Class D assault, a misdemeanor. He waived arraignment and pleaded not guilty.

Stewart said Friday he had not yet been made aware of the civil suit.

Day's attorney, Marc Beaudoin, offered a sharply different account in an email Friday. He said Day had observed the teenager using a cellphone while driving and intended to issue a summons. After she repeatedly refused commands to approach, Beaudoin wrote, Day moved to handcuff her. At that point, she attempted to pull away and kicked Day in the knee.

"Officer Day did not use any excessive force during the arrest," Beaudoin said. "The teen's injuries were inadvertent and due to her own refusal to comply."

The lawsuit, however, argues the December encounter was not an isolated lapse. It cites internal department records — obtained by the Portland Press Herald through a public records request — showing Day was formally disciplined three times before the alleged assault.

In September 2023, Day was disciplined for operating a police cruiser in violation of department policy. In July 2025, he was disciplined again for a vehicle pursuit that broke policy. Most recently, in August 2025 — four months before the parking lot incident — Day was disciplined and ordered to complete remedial training after reportedly tackling a suspect.

"While Nathan Day's actions last December are at the heart of this suit, this case is also about the lack of discipline in the Town of Brunswick's police department, which allowed Mr. Day to stay on the force despite repeated flouting of the Constitution and departmental regulations," attorneys for the plaintiff said in a joint statement Friday.

The complaint accuses the town of deliberate indifference, arguing that Brunswick failed to adequately supervise, train, or discipline Day despite escalating warning signs. It contends the municipality's inaction created an environment where constitutional violations became foreseeable.

The criminal case against Day remains pending. The civil suit is in its earliest stages; the defendants have not yet filed a formal response in court.

Author

Maine News Now

Maine News Now

Related Stories

Mexico's cartel 'godfather' convicted in American DEA agent's murder dies at age 80
NATIONALcrime5 hours ago

Mexico's cartel 'godfather' convicted in American DEA agent's murder dies at age 80

Russell Brand’s wife opens up after comedian’s rape conviction, shares message from imprisoned husband
NATIONALcrime6 hours ago

Russell Brand’s wife opens up after comedian’s rape conviction, shares message from imprisoned husband

Bangor convenience store employee assaulted during reported robbery
crime8 hours ago

Bangor convenience store employee assaulted during reported robbery