An abandoned safe was found in Falmouth — and its mysterious stash could now help heat homes


A safe containing $55,737 in cash was found behind Falmouth's Central Fire Station in August 2022. (Sophie Burchell/Staff Writer)
A puzzling stack of cash sat in the evidence room of the Falmouth Police Department for four years.
In August 2022, a resident walking the short trail through the woods between Falmouth’s Central Fire Station and the neighboring baseball fields spotted a safe on the ground and pointed it out to Falmouth police.
Cutting the safe open, police found $55,737 in bills.
“Cash of this magnitude is very unusual,” said Falmouth Police Chief John Kilbride. “I’ve never experienced anything like that in my 30 years.”
Following the discovery of the safe, Falmouth police reached out to other law enforcement across Maine and New Hampshire, asking if they had heard about a theft of a large sum of money from either an individual or a bank. The department also published newspaper notices about finding an unspecified amount of money, fulfilling their legal due diligence, said Kilbride.
Given that the cash went unclaimed and was dry in the safe — indicating it hadn’t been sitting outside for long — Kilbride said his best guess was that it was placed in the woods for a drug-related exchange.
Advertisement
After not hearing any leads for six months, the safe and its contents were officially classified as abandoned property, joining the department’s collection of unclaimed bikes, kayaks, wallets and jewelry. According to state statute, after the police department makes sufficient effort to find the owner and at least six months have passed, the chief of police can decide what to do with unclaimed property, including donate it to a nonprofit organization, trashing it or selling it to the highest bidder.
Related
Maine is holding nearly $400 million in unclaimed property. Who’s owed what? | Opinion
The Falmouth Police Department held onto the mysterious cash longer because Kilbride thought if the money was stolen from the home of an older adult, it might take more time for them or their family to notice it was missing. But after four years, he said it was time for the money to leave the evidence room.
Kilbride said he usually sends off unclaimed property as a donation to the Falmouth Lions Club’s auction or to a secondhand store. For this unusually large sum, he directed the $55,737 be deposited into the town’s account to be used for charitable purposes.
“This is the people’s money,” said Kilbride.
With a pile of cash that metaphorically fell from the sky and the direction to help residents, it didn’t take long for Town Manager Nathan Poore to craft a proposal.
“What do we do with this now? I thought now is the time to probably help people out with heating assistance,” he said.
Advertisement
The town has facilitated short-term heating assistance programs a handful of times over the past two decades, such as during the Great Recession and the pandemic. Each time, about $50,000 went to the program, said Poore.
Roughly half of Maine households rely on heating oil, with Maine consuming more residential heating oil per capita than any other state in the country, according to data from the American Community Survey. According to an announcement from the Maine Department of Energy Resources at the end of October, heating oil prices in Maine are at a record high, with costs up 82% over this time last year. Given this increase, Mainers will spend about $750 more than last fall to fill a standard 275-gallon oil tank.
Related
Maine heating oil prices hit another record high
Maine homeowners and renters can apply to the statewide Home Energy Assistance Program, which helps qualified applicants pay for heating costs. However, even with additional funds, the state assistance won’t go as far this winter, as record-high heating oil costs will reduce the average HEAP award’s purchasing power.
Falmouth residents who have completed a HEAP application and are approved will be eligible for the town’s program as well, said Poore. Awarded funds may be used toward heating fuel, an electricity bill or rent if rent includes utilities.
Poore said in the past, the town has had about 50 applicants for heating assistance. While he’s still working out the details following the Town Council’s likely approval of this allocation, Poore said he’ll probably start the program by granting $500 per applicant. Leftover funds would be distributed in additional rounds of assistance.
The Falmouth Town Council is expected to vote to approve this use of funds at its meeting Monday evening.
“I’ve never had the experience where we stumbled upon some found money and had to spend on charitable purposes,” said Poore, who has worked for the town for 20 years. “I don’t ever recall anything like this.”
Copy the Story Link
Tagged: Falmouth Police, heating assistance, LIHEAP
Sophie is a community reporter for Cumberland, Yarmouth, North Yarmouth and Falmouth and previously reported for the Forecaster. Her memories of briefly living on Mount Desert Island as a child drew her. More by Sophie Burchell



