9 mystery fingerprints from OJ Simpson murder case could hold new clues more than 30 years later

Nine Unknown Fingerprints From the 1994 O.J. Simpson Case Spark New Forensic Question
A new docuseries on the streaming platform Peacock has reignited a long‑standing mystery from the 1994 murders of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman: nine fingerprints recovered at the Bundy Drive condominium that never matched any known person in the original investigation. The series, titled “OJ’s Accomplice,” was co‑created by Ari Mark, who is urging law‑enforcement agencies to re‑examine the prints with today’s advanced forensic technology.
The Prints That Never Found a Match
During the 1995 Los Angeles Times investigation into the Bundy Drive killings, detectives collected a number of latent fingerprints from the crime scene. While most could be matched to known individuals—such as O.J. Simpson, Brown Simpson, and 58 other acquaintances—a group of nine prints remained unmatched. Fingerprint specialist Gilbert Aguilar testified that the prints were compared to those of Simpson, Brown Simpson and a list of 58 friends, relatives and acquaintances, but no match emerged. Aguilar also noted that the prints were cross‑checked against federal and state databases, yielding no results.
“The nine prints I never identified to whom they belong,” Aguilar said in the docuseries. “Back in 1994, you’re running prints through AFIS—first it checks everyone arrested by the LAPD, then Sacramento, then all the Western states.” He added that if someone had been arrested outside those jurisdictions—such as in New York or Florida—his prints would not have been found in the database.
Why the Prints Matter Now
Mark believes the passage of time and the expansion of digital fingerprint databases could turn these once‑unsolved prints into a key to a fresh lead. “You can take latent prints and analyze those in a way that you couldn’t before,” he told Fox News Digital. “If you’re looking for a match, you have a greater chance of getting one all these years later.”
The docuseries argues that the prints could belong to a third party involved in the murders, such as Joey Ippolito—a convicted drug trafficker who had ties to organized crime and who was known to be an associate of Simpson. Ippolito was arrested in 1995, became a federal informant, and died in 2006. Although a 1996 federal prosecution memorandum described him as a “remarkable source of information,” former federal prosecutor David Kelley later stated that he did not believe Ippolito had participated in the killings.
Mark said that the docuseries’ purpose is not to cast blame but to “raise enough questions that it gets a second look.” He emphasized that any new investigation would have to be supported by the families of the victims, adding, “Assuming it was something they were interested in, I think everyone deserves to know what actually happened, and if that involves a second person, third person or whatever it is, great.”
The LAPD’s Stance
An LAPD spokesperson told Fox News Digital that the investigation remains open and that the department has an obligation to pursue justice if new evidence surfaces. “At this point, there is no other information available for release,” the spokesperson said.
Despite the docuseries’ appeals, the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office has not yet responded to requests to reexamine the prints. According to the series, defense investigator Pat McKenna urged investigators to send the prints to a lab for fresh analysis, calling it a “door that’s wide open.”
Other Elements of the Case
The docuseries also revisits testimony from Sam Ippolito, a brother of Joey Ippolito, who claimed his sibling returned to an apartment on Bundy Drive on the night of the murders carrying a bag with a heavy object. Sam alleged that Joey had blood on his hands and instructed Sam to dispose of the bag after he showered. Sam’s statements have been questioned by some, and he later attempted to retract them after The New York Times declined a payment request. These accounts are part of a broader narrative that seeks to explore whether Simpson had an accomplice.
Historical Context
O.J. Simpson was acquitted of the murders in his 1995 criminal trial, but a civil jury found him liable in 1997. He later served nearly nine years in prison for unrelated armed robbery charges and died in April 2024 at age 76.
Nicole Brown Simpson’s sister, Tanya Brown, has consistently denied the theory that her sister’s murder involved more than one killer. “I think it’s impossible if you’re in her position to speculate about theories,” Brown said. “Everything about her felt like the little sister of somebody who was an unfortunate victim.”
Looking Ahead
The call to reexamine the nine unidentified prints hinges on advances in forensic science. Modern fingerprint databases are far more expansive, and improved scanning technology can reveal details that were previously invisible. If the LAPD or other investigators decide to reopen the case, they would need to locate the original prints, digitize them, and run them through contemporary automated systems.
Until such a step is taken, the prints will remain an open question in a case that continues to fascinate the public. The docuseries has already sparked debate among legal scholars, forensic experts, and the families of the victims, highlighting the enduring complexities of the O.J. Simpson murder investigation.


