7 private schools sue state over new rule for special ed student placements

A group of private schools in Maine is suing the state Department of Education over a new rule that impacts the rights of students with special needs to a free and appropriate education.
The schools take issue with an emergency order imposed over the summer, saying it was adopted without the required public input and didn’t meet the standards for an emergency. They also dispute the substance of the rule, which they argue leaves private schools with no recourse but costly federal litigation if they believe they can’t safely educate a student.
“These schools work with the highest-needs population that we have. We should be encouraging them to work with students, and encouraging them to accept placements,” said Tara Walker, an attorney representing the private schools. “A rule that forces all the liability to go to them, and gives them no opportunity to make their own safety assessments — I just think it’s bad policy.”
Every disabled student in Maine is guaranteed a public education, per federal law. If a student with a disability like autism, dyslexia or behavior issues does not have their particular needs met at the public school, they may instead attend a special private school, paid for with public tuition dollars.
Most of the time, those placements occur without issue, through an agreement between the public district and the parents. But sometimes the parties disagree about the best location for the student.
When that happens, Maine offers recourse through what’s called a due process hearing, after which an administrative officer will issue a decision. Families also have the option to resolve the matter through mediation. If the dispute is still not settled, one of the parties may appeal to federal court.
Advertisement
Related
Portland school district files suit against parents over special education reimbursement
Until this summer, the only parties named in those hearings or cases were the parents and the public school district. To address disputes that arise when private schools remove students in conflict with the public district and parents, the Maine Department of Education passed a new rule that allows private schools to be named as parties.
Seven private schools from around the state say that decision will restrict their ability to serve students by “forcing those schools into litigation every time there is an issue regarding student behavior.”
A Department of Education spokesperson declined to comment, citing active litigation.
EMERGENCY RULE
In July, the department released its new rule on an “emergency” basis, meaning it went into effect immediately and did not require the typical public comment process.
In a document laying out its decision, the department said it became concerned in 2021 that private schools believed they could unilaterally remove a disabled student for any reason without going through the legal process. After issuing a letter that clarified that schools were breaking the law if they terminated a student without going through the proper process, the department believed the issue was resolved, until a 2025 lawsuit.
Related
Lewiston private school sues state, family over ‘stay put’ rule for students with disabilities
In that case, Spurwink, a nonprofit that operates private schools for students with disabilities, alleged that a pair of parents and the Lewiston School Department were misinterpreting the state law by ordering Spurwink to keep teaching a student who had injured staff. The student, who has nonverbal autism and behavior issues, had bitten three staff members, requiring emergency medical care.
Advertisement
That student’s parents, who spoke anonymously with the Portland Press Herald, said Spurwink was aware of their son’s behavior issues when they accepted him, and argued the school violated the legal process by discharging him without any consultation. After that, he lacked structure and learning opportunities.
“He’s regressing,” the student’s father said.
That case was ultimately dismissed, but the department determined it needed a clearer policy on removal of students by private schools.
The department first worked to find a contractual solution. It proposed a plan last October and sought comment from public districts, private schools and the general public. Following an unfavorable response, the department then proposed another plan in January, modeled off Massachusetts’ process, which it said was also met with negative feedback from public schools.
“At this point, despite the department and representatives of the (districts) and private schools working hard to come to a contractual solution, there remain obstacles to bringing it to a mutually agreeable end, primarily due to the continued lack of a regulatory enforcement mechanism,” the department wrote in its reasoning document.
It then issued its emergency ruling, which stands for one year and did not require any notice or public comment. The department is seeking to make the rule permanent during the incoming legislative session.
Advertisement
‘THEY DON’T LIVE WITH THOSE RESULTS’
Rather than providing a clearer process for disputes, as the department said when it announced the rule change, the private schools feel it had the opposite effect.
Walker, the attorney for the private schools, said the department’s abandonment of the contractual solutions, which required public input, allowed it to adopt a rule without hearing from the affected parties, and she described the action as a “misuse of the emergency process.”
After taking more than a year to develop the contractual solution, the lawsuit argues, the issue hardly met the definition of an emergency.
Walker also disputed the idea that any private school she works with has “unilaterally” removed a student. Instead, she said, private schools end up bearing all of the burden for a student’s safety, but lack any mechanism to express that they can’t safely educate a student.
It’s the public school districts that hold the power to make the placement decisions, she said, but they don’t bear the liability of keeping that student safe. “If a district is keeping a student in an environment that isn’t working, they don’t live with those results,” Walker said.
She said the rule change leaves private schools with essentially only one option if they don’t think they can safely educate a student: costly and time-consuming federal litigation. In the meantime, she said, a dangerous situation might arise if they’re forced to continue teaching the student.
The schools bringing the lawsuit include two organizations that operate special purpose private schools — Central Aroostook Association in Presque Isle and Spurwink — as well as the town academies of Thornton in Saco, Washington in East Machias, Lincoln in Newcastle, Foxcroft in Dover-Foxcroft and Fryeburg Academy. The Maine Association of Independent Schools, which represents private schools across the state, is also a plaintiff.
As of Wednesday, no deadline has been set for the department to file a response.
Copy the Story Link
Tagged: Maine Department of Education, special education, spurwink
Riley covers education for the Press Herald. Before moving to Portland, she spent two years in Kenai, Alaska, reporting on local government, schools and natural resources for the public radio station KDLL. More by Riley Board





