Mon, Nov 16WeatherBangor, ME
Maine Lottery
Latest draws loading
Maine News Now

4 months after ICE shooting in Biddeford, questions linger about state and federal investigations

4 months after ICE shooting in Biddeford, questions linger about state and federal investigations
100%

Four Months After Biddeford ICE Shooting, Families Still Waiting for Investigation Updates

BIDDEFORD, Maine — It has been four months since an Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent shot and killed a Colombian father in Biddeford, and the people closest to the case say the investigation remains shrouded in silence.

David Brouillette, a federal agent and former Maine law enforcement officer, killed Johan Sebastian Durán Guerrero, 25, on July 13. Since then, his sister Elizabeth Emen has been waiting for investigators to contact her.

Despite the passage of time, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has declined to identify the agent involved or discuss Brouillette’s employment status multiple times. Neither the DHS Office of Inspector General nor the Maine Attorney General’s office has provided new details regarding their respective probes, which both announced in July.

Emen said she learned of the shooting from a relative days after it happened. When she reflected on her last communication with her brother, she found a disturbing thread connecting them. In 2021, Brouillette sent her an email containing disparaging and xenophobic remarks about her partner, who is Colombian.

Emen said the timing and content of that correspondence made the link between the message and the tragedy impossible to ignore. She has since shared the messages with reporters, hoping the revelation contributes to a complete inquiry and accountability for the Durán Guerrero family.

A History of Vetting Questions

Details surrounding how Brouillette secured his position have come under scrutiny following a national report published this week. According to interviews with federal officials cited in that reporting, Brouillette had not been fully vetted at the time of the shooting.

The report also brought to light a lengthy legal history involving the agent. Kennebec County court records show more than eight protection from abuse filings involving Brouillette. Both of his ex-wives have alleged physical and verbal abuse.

Ashley Brouillette, the agent’s ex-wife, confirmed David Brouillette’s identity to media outlets in the week following the shooting. She said she spoke with investigators from the state and the DHS office on July 28. She recalled that officials questioned her about his mental health and medication history, asking whether she believed he was fit for the role.

Her answer was unequivocal.

“Absolutely not,” Ashley Brouillette said. “I don’t think he’s fit to work any job with any kind of weapon.”

Family members have raised concerns about the agent’s mental health and behavior in the past. Elizabeth Emen noted that while their relationship had moments of closeness and openness as adults, it was also marked by bias and judgment. In his final email to her in 2021, which she described as containing several typos, Brouillette told her the man “can takes his non citizen ass back to his country” and later wrote, “You’re dead to me Liz.”

Martha Karolina Rojas Alvarez, Durán Guerrero’s partner, reacted to the recent reporting with shock and distress. She said the revelation that the agent may not have been properly vetted was unforgivable.

“Why would they give him a gun?” Rojas Alvarez asked. “That is unforgivable, even in God’s eyes. And I can never forgive that man for taking the love of my life from me and for taking my daughter’s father from her. I hope justice is served.”

Investigative Dead Ends and Political Pressure

Durán Guerrero’s legal team reports hearing nothing from federal investigators. Lawyers have expressed doubt regarding the scope of the federal review after a Justice Department official told CBS that the FBI is not conducting a civil rights review of the shooting.

Meanwhile, ICE communicated with Rep. Chellie Pingree for the first time this week. The agency confirmed in writing to the congresswoman’s office that it has an ongoing investigation, though it provided no specifics. This came in response to a letter Pingree sent to DHS in July asking about hiring and training practices and whether the agency would review its operation in Biddeford.

At the state level, Attorney General Aaron Frey’s office is reviewing whether criminal conduct occurred and whether the use of deadly force was justified. Sean Murphy, an attorney for the victim’s family, said AG staff indicated a desire to finalize their determination before Frey’s term ends. State lawmakers are scheduled to elect a new attorney general on Dec. 2. There is no state law preventing a successor from making their own decision regarding the shooting.

Once the AG decides, the case could move to Maine’s deadly force review panel. The panel, composed of law enforcement officials, prosecutors, forensic experts and civilians, assesses whether a shooting adheres to best practices.

Panel Chair Stephen Burlock, a former prosecutor, said the group has not received any information about the Biddeford case. Sheriff Joel Merry, a panel member, noted the group reviews cases chronologically and is currently working through a shooting that occurred in late 2024. Even if the AG refers the matter soon, Merry suggested other cases would need to be reviewed first.

Congressional Democrats are also positioning themselves for future oversight. Rep. Bennie Thompson, the top Democrat on the House Homeland Security Committee, who is set to lead the committee next year, said those who empowered Brouillette must be held accountable. Other Democrats have signaled they plan to investigate the shooting and review DHS funding through next year.

The Road to a Decision

While the investigations continue, the victim’s family faces practical challenges alongside their grief. Durán Guerrero’s attorneys said the state has not yet returned the car the victim was driving when he was shot.

Biddeford Mayor Liam LaFountain said he stays in regular contact with the Attorney General’s office but had no new information to share Thursday. He acknowledged that investigators may need to withhold details to protect the integrity of an active probe.

“A thorough investigation takes time, but Johan’s family also deserves timely answers and swift justice,” LaFountain said.

Brouillette himself has not responded to requests for comment regarding the incident. He was placed on leave following the shooting, a fact the Attorney General’s office acknowledged in July but DHS has declined to address.

For Elizabeth Emen, the delay remains the most striking part of the experience. She hopes her cooperation will eventually lead to full transparency.

“The fact that there are multiple reports, including my experience, of my brother having biased beliefs, and violent behavior, I think speaks a lot to the systems that gave him power and authority and a weapon,” Emen said.

Author

Maine News Now

Maine News Now

Related Stories

Mexico's cartel 'godfather' convicted in American DEA agent's murder dies at age 80
NATIONALcrime5 hours ago

Mexico's cartel 'godfather' convicted in American DEA agent's murder dies at age 80

Russell Brand’s wife opens up after comedian’s rape conviction, shares message from imprisoned husband
NATIONALcrime6 hours ago

Russell Brand’s wife opens up after comedian’s rape conviction, shares message from imprisoned husband

Bangor convenience store employee assaulted during reported robbery
crime8 hours ago

Bangor convenience store employee assaulted during reported robbery