11-night Caribbean cruise abruptly canceled after Coast Guard detains ship

MSC Poesia Detained in Miami, 11‑Night Caribbean Cruise Cancelled
Miami, Fla. – The MSC Poesia was stopped in port by the U.S. Coast Guard on Sunday, Nov. 3, after officials flagged problems with the ship’s onboard systems. The luxury cruise ship, which was due to set sail on Nov. 1 for an 11‑night Caribbean itinerary, was ordered to remain in Miami until the deficiencies were corrected. MSC Cruises has announced the voyage will not resume and will refund passengers in full.
The MSC Poesia was slated to depart from the Port of Miami on Nov. 1 and return on Nov. 12, visiting Jamaica, Colombia, Panama, Costa Rica, Honduras and Belize. At the time of detainment, more than 2,000 guests and crew were aboard, according to the cruise‑review site Cruise Critic. The ship’s captain, Capt. Frank Florio, commander of the U.S. Coast Guard Sector Miami, said the Coast Guard had identified “deficiencies with systems on board the vessel” and was working with MSC to address them.
“While we cannot comment on the specifics of the ongoing Port State Control Examination, we have identified deficiencies with systems on board the vessel that we are addressing with MSC,” Florio said in a Coast Guard press release.
MSC’s spokesperson acknowledged the disruption and promised financial relief. “We have made the difficult decision to cancel the current sailing,” the spokesperson told Fox News Digital. “We recognize how disappointing and frustrating this news is for our guests, and we sincerely apologize for the disruption to their holiday.” The company also explained that a “regulatory matter arose that required resolution” before departure and that it “could not resolve it in time” for the ship to sail. Passengers will receive a full refund and assistance with travel arrangements back home.
The Coast Guard’s Port State Control (PSC) program inspects foreign‑flagged commercial vessels that call at U.S. ports to ensure compliance with safety, security and environmental standards. When substantial noncompliance is found, the Coast Guard may detain a vessel until the issues are remedied. According to the agency’s release, the MSC Poesia will remain in Miami until the identified problems are fixed and the ship is cleared to depart.
“The fact that this cruise ship was detained with passengers on board when it was about to embark on its voyage tells you the Coast Guard found something significant enough to warrant a detention,” said Alex Perez, maritime attorney at Miami firm Lipcon, Margulies & Winkleman. Perez noted that while cruise ships in U.S. ports are inspected frequently, detainment is “very rare for a ship carrying thousands of people.” He added that the Coast Guard has broad authority to inspect and board foreign‑flagged vessels in U.S. waters.
Passengers on the ship have expressed a mix of disappointment and gratitude for the company’s response. One Reddit user, who had been aboard since Sept. 28, wrote: “We have been on board the MSC Poesia since 28 September… although we’re disappointed that the last part of our extended back‑to‑back cruise was canceled, we appreciate the compensation MSC has offered and the practical help they’re providing to get us home.”
Others on the same forum speculated about the cause of the detainment, noting that the ship’s contract with MSC explicitly prohibits class‑action lawsuits. “Cruise ship contracts prohibit class actions,” Perez explained. “So in a case like this, they cannot do class actions to group themselves together and make it easier for the passenger to get relief.”
Passengers who wish to seek compensation can file individual claims, but the binding ticket contract requires that they do so on a case‑by‑case basis. The contract also requires passengers to waive the right to join a group lawsuit.
The MSC Poesia remains docked at the Port of Miami while Coast Guard inspectors continue to assess the ship’s systems. The MSC organization is working with the Coast Guard to resolve the deficiencies and to determine when, if at all, the vessel can resume its Caribbean itinerary. For now, guests who had booked the 11‑night cruise will be refunded and offered assistance with alternative travel arrangements.

